Weight Loss Forum / Low Carb / March 2010
Sort of OT: Software to track Vitamin K?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Marengo - 08 Mar 2010 21:27 GMT For those who don't know me (this isn't spam!) I'm a former long-time poster here on ASDLC (since 2000) and after losing about 50 pounds on Atkins, for the past couple of years I've been maintaining my weight and ideal blood sugar and lipid levels with a low glycemic diet. I've been tracking everything I eat on FitDay.
My life just got a whole lot more complicated when my cardiologist started me on a Coumadin regimen last week to prevent a possible stroke from blood clots forming in my atrial valves due to a diagnosis of chronic paroxysmal atrial fibrillation. Vitamin K interferes with the blood thinning attributes of Coumadin, and I must consume a consistent amount of Vitamin K in my foods from day to day so that the medication can counterbalance it without over-thinning my blood, or letting it get too thick. This is crucial.
Normally this would be easier for me to track than for a lot of people because I'm so OCD about recoding everything I eat anyway in Fitday. I love Fitday and have been using it almost obsessive for many years, but now I find it has a major drawback... it is not capable of tracking Vitamin K, and FitDay's nutrients are not customizable. This is a real pain. I need to find some software ASAP that works similarly to FitDay but also has the capability of adding or customizing nutrients so I can track the Vitamin K also. I really don't relish the prospect of keeping a completely separate spreadsheet every day to track my Vitamin K consumption.
TIA --- Peter
Susan - 08 Mar 2010 21:51 GMT > For those who don't know me (this isn't spam!) I'm a former long-time > poster here on ASDLC (since 2000) and after losing about 50 pounds on [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > don't relish the prospect of keeping a completely separate spreadsheet > every day to track my Vitamin K consumption. Peter, I'm sorry for this new problem! I wonder if your doctor would totally freak out if you used fish oil instead of Coumadin as a blood thinner, and are you on K Dur or other potassium supplement? Potassium levels are hard to get accurate tests on due to bad lab practices, but I know I get awful arrhythmia without K Dur, often.
http://content.onlinejacc.org/cgi/content/full/j.jacc.2007.05.045v1
http://circ.ahajournals.org/cgi/content/full/110/4/368
http://heartdisease.about.com/od/atrialfibrillation/a/omega3af.htm
http://www.mind1st.co.uk/Atrial-Fibrillation-case-study-Warafin.asp
http://my.clevelandclinic.org/heart/askdoctor/afib_potassium.aspx
Doctors are too quick to give you an rx drug instead of a careful evaluation of your electrolyte and adrenal hormone balance (regulates blood electrolytes and heart rhythm).
Susan
Marengo - 08 Mar 2010 23:23 GMT >x-no-archive: yes > [quoted text clipped - 45 lines] > >Susan Hi Susan,
I've had the a-fib for 2-1/2 years now and up til now have done exactly what you mentioned. I've resisted the Coumadin treatment and instead have relied on supplements... magnesium, fish oil, vitamin e and others. I've had extensive bloodwork done and electrolytes and cortisol levels are normal. The only thing off is slightly low thyroid hormone.
It's a complex situation. I've been taking Plavix since 10/2007 to prevent thrombosis in drug-eluting coronary artery stents. But because I had a previous ischemic stroke in 1998, my cardiologist (actually, two of them) insisted that the risk of another stroke from the a-fib is 70 X the risk of stent thrombosis from stopping the Plavix. He finally said that I had to stop taking the Plavix and start taking Coumadin, and said he could not be responsible if I refused any longer to take it. This is not some joe shmo, he's the head of Clinical Cardiac Electrophysiology in one of the top Heart Hospitals in the country and is an expert on atrial fibrillation and metabolic diseases that affect the heart. I finally caved and agreed to the Coumadin; at this point I think it would be foolish not to. It will be a safer way to balance my diet with measurable critical blood viscosity than my self-prescribed supplements.
This all sounds scary when I put it in writing, but I don't feel that way at all. I've had both excellent medical treatment and have a tremendous impact on maintaining my own health through my controlled carb/low glycemic diet and supplements. These medical issues are hereditary. My father had two heart attacks in his 40's and died from a stroke at 59. My brother died last year at 54 from CAD after a series of angioplasties. I'm now 58. But neither my father nor my brother addressed their health proactively as I do, so I'm not especially concerned about premature death from genetic CAD as happened with them.
This is the main reason I intend to diligently track the Vitamin K. Yes, I know that it's more difficult to accurately track than other nutrients but at least being in the ballpark will do. I'm not thrilled about being on Coumadin or having to record yet another nutrient, and I would much prefer to do it naturally... but I'm very determined that if I have to do it, then by gosh I'm going to be the best damned Vitamin K tracker and have the most stable Coumadin levels of anybody my cardiologist has treated!
I had to stop taking my vitamin E and fish oil because I cannot mix them with Coumadin. However, I've increased the amount of fish that I eat from once or twice a week to four or five days a week. Hopefully that will help somewhat with the a-fib along with the magnesium supplements.
Thanks for the concern, and thanks for the links.
--- Peter
Susan - 08 Mar 2010 23:32 GMT > I've had the a-fib for 2-1/2 years now and up til now have done > exactly what you mentioned. I've resisted the Coumadin treatment and > instead have relied on supplements... magnesium, fish oil, vitamin e > and others. I've had extensive bloodwork done and electrolytes and > cortisol levels are normal. The only thing off is slightly low thyroid > hormone. What about time released potassium? How many times and by how many different methods was your cortisol tested? I've tested a zillion times; most normal even at my most symptomatic, and several out of the park high when I felt fine. Tends to cycle or be episodic. Some folks never test positive on urine, only serum, some only at midnight or ten hour urine tests.
And what about aldosterone, renin, etc?
> It's a complex situation. I've been taking Plavix since 10/2007 to > prevent thrombosis in drug-eluting coronary artery stents. But [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > will be a safer way to balance my diet with measurable critical blood > viscosity than my self-prescribed supplements. Peter, I certainly understand your need to follow his advice, but I urge you to ask for, demand, find someone to do all the other testing, too. It's not enough for him to write an rx and stop thinking about your causation, IMO.
I'll just add that my worst iatrogenic injuries have come at the hands of world renown academic medical dept. heads or their prodigies, and negligence as well, for decades. Many of them, so don't be lulled into a sense of security by credentials. They all eff up and once you research your conditions you realize how stupid and inept almost all of them are. Really.
> This all sounds scary when I put it in writing, but I don't feel that > way at all. I've had both excellent medical treatment and have a [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > especially concerned about premature death from genetic CAD as > happened with them. Predispositions are hereditary, but not the diseases they cause, necessarily. Further, the endocrine imbalances that cause them do cause disease, but you don't have to have the worst possible progression. I know you've been through so much already.
> This is the main reason I intend to diligently track the Vitamin K. > Yes, I know that it's more difficult to accurately track than other [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > best damned Vitamin K tracker and have the most stable Coumadin levels > of anybody my cardiologist has treated! Have you found the USDA nutrient database online? You can download it and create a desktop icon/shortcut easily.
> I had to stop taking my vitamin E and fish oil because I cannot mix > them with Coumadin. However, I've increased the amount of fish that I [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > Thanks for the concern, and thanks for the links. Take good care of yourself, and never take your doctor's word for anything without researching it yourself on PubMed and elsewhere. Saved my life and my kid's that way...
Susan
Marengo - 08 Mar 2010 23:47 GMT >Have you found the USDA nutrient database online? You can download it >and create a desktop icon/shortcut easily. It's my Bible! :-) --- Peter
Joan F (MI) - 08 Mar 2010 22:03 GMT My SO is on Coumadin. The easiest way to do this is to completely avoid Vitamin K rich foods, but you miss a lot of good stuff, salad greens, asparagus, spinach, broccoli. Since I'm the cook, I'm in control of his diet. We have a rule of one K food a day, most of the time it's a salad but we skip the salad when we have asparagus, spinach or broccoli. He has a blood test every month and his levels stay pretty constant. I really don't think it varies day by day but rather averages out of a several day period. It's harder to count Vit K than calories, and I'm doubtful that it is constant in identical vegetables as they have different growing conditions. There really aren't many vegetables that are high in K so you could just figure out the value for a serving of each of your common ones and make sure you have an approximately equal amount every day.
| For those who don't know me (this isn't spam!) I'm a former long-time | poster here on ASDLC (since 2000) and after losing about 50 pounds on [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] | --- | Peter Doug Freyburger - 08 Mar 2010 22:57 GMT > My SO is on Coumadin. The easiest way to do this is to completely avoid > Vitamin K rich foods, but you miss a lot of good stuff, salad greens, > asparagus, spinach, broccoli. Those are core foods of many/most of us low carbers. Yikes.
Susan - 08 Mar 2010 23:24 GMT > Those are core foods of many/most of us low carbers. Yikes. I haven't researched this at all, but if the drug or other anti thrombotic works, why on earth would you have to avoid vit K?
Better yet; if you get your electrolytes balanced, you might not need anti thrombotic therapy at all.
Susan
Joan F (MI) - 09 Mar 2010 00:49 GMT Vitamin K works in the opposite direction of Coumadin. My SO has a genetic tendency toward blot clots, this all started when he had a pain in his chest and coughed up blood. Found he had a clot in his leg some of which had migrated up to his lungs. Was in the hospital several days while they dissolved it. He'd rather not take chances of it happening again.
| I haven't researched this at all, but if the drug or other anti | thrombotic works, why on earth would you have to avoid vit K? [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] | | Susan Susan - 09 Mar 2010 01:48 GMT > Vitamin K works in the opposite direction of Coumadin. Yes, I know.
But not eating vegetables is super unhealthy, too.
As long as the Coumadin is working and one maintains a fairly consistent level of veggies, one doesn't have to create a new health problem in addition.
Susan
Joan F (MI) - 09 Mar 2010 03:35 GMT Isn't that what I said we did?
| x-no-archive: yes | > Vitamin K works in the opposite direction of Coumadin. [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] | | Susan Marengo - 09 Mar 2010 04:32 GMT >x-no-archive: yes >> Vitamin K works in the opposite direction of Coumadin. [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > >Susan Yep. That's the "modern" thinking. Until fairly recently they used to say "no green vegetables" period when one was on Coumadin because it counteracted the drug. But now that's been changed to "stay consistent with the amount of green vegetables you eat," and the Coumadin is adjusted to compensate. It makes a lot more sense. I can eat all but the most Vitamn-K laden vegetables (some veggies like kale and spinach are uber-high in V-K, and literally have hundreds of times what, say, green beans have. THose are the only ones I have to completely avoid.
But this all goes back to my original question. I'm trying to find nutritional software that has the capability of tracking V-K in daily foods -- or at least one where the user can add a nutrient. This evening I spent a couple of hours making an Excel spreadsheet that will work, but it's already a real pain in the neck manually entering all the foods and nutritional values.
I imagine though, that after a learning curve I should get to know the foods and will just "know" what I can and cannot eat, just as I know now which foods have hidden sugars and starches. Then I hopefully won't have to keep detailed track every day. In the meanwhile I go for blood tests 2X a week until my INR (formerly pro-time)is stabilized. --- Peter
Marengo - 08 Mar 2010 23:41 GMT >> My SO is on Coumadin. The easiest way to do this is to completely avoid >> Vitamin K rich foods, but you miss a lot of good stuff, salad greens, >> asparagus, spinach, broccoli. > >Those are core foods of many/most of us low carbers. Yikes. Ain't that the truth! --- Peter
Joan F (MI) - 09 Mar 2010 00:47 GMT Well, you just have to eat them in fairly constant doses. One serving per day works for us but you could do two or three servings just as well.
| Those are core foods of many/most of us low carbers. Yikes. Marengo - 09 Mar 2010 04:37 GMT On Mon, 8 Mar 2010 19:47:19 -0500, "Joan F \(MI\)" <jjfahl@removethisameritech.net> wrote:
>Well, you just have to eat them in fairly constant doses. One serving per >day works for us but you could do two or three servings just as well. > >| Those are core foods of many/most of us low carbers. Yikes. I started counting mcg of Vitamin K today, and I'm purposely starting relatively high. I figure that at the end of the day if I've haven't eaten enough foods with VK it will be easier to eat a cup of green beans or gnaw on some raw green pepper in the evening than it would be to purge if I had eaten too much! ;-D --- Peter
Marengo - 08 Mar 2010 23:39 GMT On Mon, 8 Mar 2010 17:03:09 -0500, "Joan F \(MI\)" <jjfahl@removethisameritech.net> wrote:
>My SO is on Coumadin. The easiest way to do this is to completely avoid >Vitamin K rich foods, but you miss a lot of good stuff, salad greens, [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] >figure out the value for a serving of each of your common ones and make sure >you have an approximately equal amount every day. I was on Coumadin previously for a year following a stroke in 1998, and back then the standard recommendation was doing exactly what you just mentioned... cutting out the Vitamin K laden foods, mostly green vegetables, vegetable and olive oils and some berries and certain fruit. My weight shot up from 180 pounds to 270 pounds in that one year, and I eventually developed metabolic syndrome. It took me eight years and a low carb/low glycemic regimen to stabilize my weight, blood chemistry and blood sugar at healthy levels after gaining all that weight so rapidly on that ungodly diet!
Fortunately the thinking has changed now and the recommendation made by the cardiologists is not to omit those foods when starting on Coumadin, but rather to be consistent. In other words, I can still eat my green beans, celery, certain kinds of lettuce, cucumbers, cauliflower etc. and use my olive oil for cooking... provided that I am consistent with the intake from one week to the next. I won't have a problem with that. I only have to avoid the greens that are extremely high in Vitamin K like Spinach, Kale and Collars and to a lesser extent broccoli.
--- Peter
Doug Freyburger - 09 Mar 2010 17:28 GMT > .... In other words, I can still > eat my green beans, celery, certain kinds of lettuce, cucumbers, [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > extremely high in Vitamin K like Spinach, Kale and Collars and to a > lesser extent broccoli. Ah. When I started low carbing I trained myself to pay attention to carb counts and I've been selecting my veggies types based on that ever since. As long as there are plenty of low-K types that's just another filter to learn. Lot's of work early on then it gets easy.
Marengo - 09 Mar 2010 19:28 GMT >> .... In other words, I can still >> eat my green beans, celery, certain kinds of lettuce, cucumbers, [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] >since. As long as there are plenty of low-K types that's just another >filter to learn. Lot's of work early on then it gets easy. Yep. That's what I figure. Just another filter to learn... ergo my search for FitDay-type software that can track Vitamin K along with the macronutrients and the common vitamins and minerals. --- Peter
Bill who putters - 08 Mar 2010 22:03 GMT > For those who don't know me (this isn't spam!) I'm a former long-time > poster here on ASDLC (since 2000) and after losing about 50 pounds on [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] > --- > Peter I was thinking perhaps some D3 or at least sunshine.
Some stuff below to peruse on a rainy day.
<http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez?Db=pubmed&term=warfarin%20natto %20vitamin%20k&linkpos=2&log$=related_queries>
 Signature Bill Garden in shade zone 5 S Jersey USA <http://www.globalissues.org/article/75/world-military-spending>
|
|
|