Weight Loss Forum / Low Carb / March 2004
Getting tired of this stall
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Bear - 03 Mar 2004 14:27 GMT I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've never had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with but I did lose a few pounds (at least) each week. I feel great but I'm getting very frustrated over this. I'm thinking that for a few days I was going to use some of the leftover Opti fast shakes I have just to give myself a push. It doesn't seem that a few days of this will hurt. But went to get them and realized I through them all out when I started this. I've been very careful to eat right and have not been using any bars, shakes or anything like that. My portion size has been normal. In fact I cut back on breakfast a little. I was having 4 slices of bacon and have cut back to 3, with breakfast. I have avoided my injection of testosterone and have been taking my lasix. I had dropped to 269 on Friday but after Saturdays dinner I wasn't surprised to see that I weighed 273. Today its 274.5. I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have.
 Signature Bear Grrrrrrrrrrrr :o) 297/271/210 Highest weight 353 http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html
Crafting Mom - 03 Mar 2004 14:55 GMT > I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've > never had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm > experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. Give your body time to adjust. The human body is complex and does not work the same way a calculator works when you push the correct buttons. Weight loss is one of the many benefits. And if you are on a way of eating for life, blackmailing your body with "You lose weight or I go off this diet", will seem ridiculous, and backfire worse than any "stall". Give your body time is the best advice I can give. Then, check to see if your calorie intake is appropriate. CM
Jean Staffen - 03 Mar 2004 15:09 GMT If I'm reading your website correctly, you've lost 26 lbs since January - that is two months. Right? I think that is one whale of a job. I've lost 22 lbs since 11/03 and I'm pround of myself. I think Crafting Mom is right - cut yourself some slack.
> I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've never > had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with but I [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm > experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. Chet Hayes - 04 Mar 2004 01:00 GMT > If I'm reading your website correctly, you've lost 26 lbs since January - > that is two months. Right? I think that is one whale of a job. I've lost > 22 lbs since 11/03 and I'm pround of myself. I think Crafting Mom is right - > cut yourself some slack. If that's the case, then what we have here is another case of unreasonable expectations.
> > I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've > never [quoted text clipped - 19 lines] > > I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm > > experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. Roger Zoul - 03 Mar 2004 15:34 GMT 1) fitday.com. Count everything.
2) more regular exercise
3) get hungry between every meal -- hunger won't kill you -- if you get so hungry that it really bothers you, just enough enough to relieve it.
Those few new pounds mean nothing - don't sweat them.
There is no reason someone your size cannot expect continuous weight loss, barring some extreme metabolic issues (which always seem to defy logic).
What you are dealing with now is just the kind of hit-and-miss weight loss that drove me to start counting everything (it not as hard as you may envision it to be).
I know you probably won't listen to me, but I'm not going to give up on you, Bear! :)
:: I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. :: I've never had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to [quoted text clipped - 19 lines] :: Highest weight 353 :: http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html Bear - 03 Mar 2004 16:22 GMT Hey Roger- I'm not the kind of man who can't learn from his mistakes. I'm listening. And even more so now. I thought about what you said about counting calories when I was writing the OP.
 Signature Bear Grrrrrrrrrrrr :o) 297/271/210 Highest weight 353 http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html
> 1) fitday.com. Count everything. > [quoted text clipped - 38 lines] > :: Highest weight 353 > :: http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html DigitalVinyl - 03 Mar 2004 19:47 GMT >Hey Roger- >I'm not the kind of man who can't learn from his mistakes. I'm listening. >And even more so now. I thought about what you said about counting calories >when I was writing the OP. Can't let frustration get to you. The loss will happen. Just have to figure out how your body works and work with it. I'm going through upping my carbs to find my CCLL and after 5 steady weeks of weight loss I'm now seeing ups and downs and for the last week, a slowing. It is frutsrating, I'd rather see the number decreasing consistently as before, but I want to find my CCLL. I also need to prove out, to myself, that I can lose weight just as well at my CCLL(be 30,40,50 carbs) as at 20, which is the theory.
I know one of Atkin's appeal is the whole "you don't have to count" deal, but for retraining yourself, I think counting is very useful for getting used to different portions and truly understanding the composition of what goes in your mouth. After a few weeks you just start remembering stuff and counting become a little more intuitive. Hopefully, eventually, it will become natural to just "know".
For me it is a policing action. Last night made some spicy taco meat with onions, jalapenos, tomatoes; ate one LC tortilla and the rest on lettuce. Used too much and made too much. I was 0.8 carbs over for the day--no biggie, but in my mind it put my estimates in check and told me, I was overdoing. (Spices are a hidden carb, many ground spices have about 1 carb per teaspoon. Herbs and leafy spices are lower.) Without counting I think carb creep would happen too easily. And I think I'm too early in this to just wing it.
One general tip: Online grocers nutrition info online. I use www.peapod.com Even if you aren't going to shop there you can still browse through the aisles from the comfort of home and find which brands are lower carbs than other. PeaPod will sort all the items in a group in order by price/carbs/fiber/protein/fat/etc. Sometimes quite amazing how much diference there is from brand to brand of the same product. It's much easier than standing around in the store aisles. That's where counting starts for me. Buying choices that are generally lower carbs.
DiGiTAL_ViNYL (no email) 350/325/Mar-315/200 Atkins since 1/12/2004
DigitalVinyl - 03 Mar 2004 20:33 GMT >I also need to prove out, to >myself, that I can lose weight just as well at my CCLL(be 30,40,50 >carbs) as at 20, which is the theory. Oops, what I meant to say is lose at the same rate closer to my CCLL than staying at Induction levels.
DiGiTAL_ViNYL (no email) 350/325/Mar-315/200 Atkins since 1/12/2004
Doug Freyburger - 04 Mar 2004 14:30 GMT > I know one of Atkin's appeal is the whole "you don't have to count" > deal Except for the fact that counting is required from day one.
> After a few weeks you just > start remembering stuff and counting become a little more intuitive. > Hopefully, eventually, it will become natural to just "know". Right. 'Just "know"' is still counting.
Early on the more exact your count the better control you have, and the Atkins process is counting your carbs and your ketosis, plus the ill-defined half that is identifying and isolating problem foods.
Once you've found your CCLL by spending a week out of ketosis, less accurate counts start to work fine. Then accurate counts are needed to find your CCLM. And then once on maintenance less accurate counts once again work fine.
During two main phases of the process eyeballing by portion is good enough, but it still counts as counting. But by the time you are counting via portions, it is extremely easy to count.
Sunshyne - 03 Mar 2004 20:24 GMT > 1) fitday.com. Count everything. > [quoted text clipped - 38 lines] > :: Highest weight 353 > :: http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html I always get a kick out of your "Grrrrrrrrrrr". It makes me laugh. You hang in there. You are so kind to me, when I post things. I appreciate that. You will, you can, get through this stall. I believe in you.
I am learning too, with what you are going through. So when I do stall, I know what to do.
:) Smile for you. You mention Lasix. Why do you take that? Is there anyway that the Lasix could be the problem? Is there anyway that you could go off it for a week to see if it is the cause? I read in the Atkins book, that it could be a problem with weight loss.
Bear - 04 Mar 2004 00:14 GMT Hey Sunshyne-I'm glad I give you a chuckle and thanks for the smile. Also it's easy be kind to nice people. :o) The lasix is a very strong diuretic medication that I take for high blood pressure. If I take it I shed water easily. If I don't I can feel the water weight pile on. Your reply to my post made my day.
 Signature Bear Grrrrrrrrrrrr :o) 297/271/210 Highest weight 353 http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html
> I always get a kick out of your "Grrrrrrrrrrr". It makes me laugh. You > hang in there. You are so kind to me, when I post things. I appreciate [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > for a week to see if it is the cause? I read in the Atkins book, that > it could be a problem with weight loss. PJx - 03 Mar 2004 16:33 GMT >I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've never >had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with but I [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] >I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm >experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. I suggest you fast. Over a billion people do it successfuly at regular intervals without any ill effects (mostly for religious reasons).
PJ
curt - 03 Mar 2004 20:37 GMT This happens to us all. It will go your way sooner or later. Just be patient. You are still doing very well and there is bound to be a little stall here and there. It gets a little harder as you lose, but then you may have a couple good weeks and lose a tidy sum again.
Hang in there, Curt
> I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've never > had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with but I [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm > experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. Doug Freyburger - 03 Mar 2004 20:44 GMT > I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. According to your web page you've stayed in phase 1. No surprise then. Doing that causes a *lot* of people to stall. Move on to OWL and allow the loss to resume. OWL is called ongoing "weight loss" for a reason. Step out in faith!
Keep upping those carbs until you've spent a week out of ketosis to find your CCLL. The single most important concept in the entire Atkins process, CCLL, less is not more.
Bear - 04 Mar 2004 00:16 GMT I know you're right. I'll remember your phrase - *Step out in faith!*
 Signature Bear Grrrrrrrrrrrr :o) 297/271/210 Highest weight 353 http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html
> > I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. > [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > to find your CCLL. The single most important concept in the > entire Atkins process, CCLL, less is not more. diane - 04 Mar 2004 00:33 GMT Are you taking any supplements while on low carb? I just got an article in a health magazine " energy times" about hitting a plateau. Quote: remember the trick to restarting weight loss is getting the nutrients you need to reignite your diet: A healthy range of vitamins and minerals, along with amino acids such as taurine and carnitine, help your body liberate energy from stored fat, which helps get weight loss back on track.
I've been on the Atkins supplements since I started ( it gave me reassurance I wasn't missing anything and the content was complete) At Wal-Mart, the 14 starter kit, is a better value than the 3 individual supps. I was buying. The starter kit has the recommended "core 4" and comes with a free sample of Accel which advertises "perfect for those who have reached a plateau"
I haven't opened this sample of Accel yet. They are expensive on the Atkins website, but contain
Chromium (as polynicotinate) 100 MCG 83% Niacin 15 mg 75% Green Tea Leaf Extract 600 mg *%
These are easy to find in the drug store. This is the first reference to supplements and stalls that I have noticed- but it makes some sense. The biggest component in accel is the green tea extract...can't hurt trying this.
 Signature Diane Atkins since 12/4/2003 234/209/150 5"8
> I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've never > had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with but I [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm > experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. Bear - 04 Mar 2004 00:44 GMT That's interesting and given what Doug posted in another thread, I may be missing a lot of nutrients that are neccessary for continued loss. I have been taking a supplement but it's just a one a day from walgreens. I think I'll add more carbs, track what I'm eating on fitday (ok Roger you win) and find my CCLL.
 Signature Bear Grrrrrrrrrrrr :o) 297/271/210 Highest weight 353 http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html
> Are you taking any supplements while on low carb? I just got an article in > a health magazine " energy times" about hitting a plateau. Quote: remember [quoted text clipped - 43 lines] > > I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm > > experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. Piedlourde - 04 Mar 2004 03:24 GMT << I'll add more carbs, track what I'm eating on fitday (ok Roger you win) and find my CCLL. >>
Way to go, Bear!
I finally moved on into OWL-- with less weight lost than you!!-- on Monday, after exactly 2 months on Induction. It's HARD to eat the five extra carbs-- not hungry!!-- but I'm doin' it. Sticking to veggies for now, maybe next week there will be some seeds and nuts in my life again...
Fitday is GREAT. I've totally given up on the Atkins.com journal. That website doesn't seem to load for me anymore anyway, it's really weird...
Anyway... marching bravely onward,
Piedlourde
Paper - 04 Mar 2004 13:36 GMT >That's interesting and given what Doug posted in another thread, I may be >missing a lot of nutrients that are neccessary for continued loss. I have >been taking a supplement but it's just a one a day from walgreens. I think >I'll add more carbs, track what I'm eating on fitday (ok Roger you win) and >find my CCLL. Call me a sucker, but I just bought the Fitday software. It's a bit more comprehensive than the site, and for a geek-girl like me, it's another toy to play with.
Tracking on Fitday is probably the best thing you can do for yourself, because you can actually SEE what's going on with your plan. Don't forget to factor in your exercise.
Paper
If it's not one thing - it's your mother. 225/224/150
Doug Freyburger - 04 Mar 2004 14:25 GMT > That's interesting and given what Doug posted in another thread, I may be > missing a lot of nutrients that are neccessary for continued loss. Jumping to a false conclusion may be good exercise, but it doesn't work that way.
The entire reason it is *safe* to remain on Induction for as long as 6 months is as long as you follow the rules carefully you get plenty of nutrients from your food. Supplementation is to overcome the problems of modern agriculture and really apply to everyone not just low carbers.
The reason people give themselves self inflicted stalls by staying low is the false idea that less is more, missing the single most important concept in the entire Atkins process. It is obvious that eating less carbs should lead to more loss, but it's also obvious that you can only get fat by eating fat. Obvious does not mean true.
The reason moving up triggers better loss is the same reason why the 6 month limit is a safety limit. It is the second level of hormone blood levels. Level 1 is inside the cell in aerobic respiration boichemistry. Level 2 is the insulin and glucagon in the bllod. Level 3 is the T3 thyroid and leptin in the blood. I suspect that level 4 is the seratonin and melatonin in the blood but I haven't had time to do the studies to confirm that.
Set your carbs low enough and beginning 3 weeks later, T3 thyroid output drops causing reduced basal metabolic rate. Bingo the self induced stalls of staying low that are so common. Bingo why OWL works in the first place. And when you through in the fact that blood leptin levels also throttle ketosis, bingo why those few Eskimos and Inuits who still live the traditional hunting lifestyle aren't in ketosis and why there's that 6 month safety limit on staying low.
It ain't the vitamins. It's the carbs. The single most important concept in the entire Atkins process, that carbs are the tool not the enemy.
JC Der Koenig - 04 Mar 2004 02:09 GMT What a surprise, Mr. Faux-food eating fat boy. Weren't you just telling me you knew all the secrets to weight loss? Yes you were. Too bad for you.
 Signature Most of us probably aren't in danger of eating too little. :)
Becky P.
> I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've never > had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with but I [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm > experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. JC Der Koenig - 04 Mar 2004 02:10 GMT Oh yeah, I guess I shouldn't say anything or else you'll get your feelings hurt and threaten to leave the group again like the drama queen that you are.
 Signature Most of us probably aren't in danger of eating too little. :)
Becky P.
> I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've never > had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with but I [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > I don't know what to do. I'm not going to give up on this WOE because I'm > experiencing other benefits and I do feel better having lost what I have. CarbAddict - 06 Mar 2004 06:09 GMT > From: JC Der Koenig (Thu, 04 Mar 2004 02:10:52 GMT) > MsgId: <Mew1c.7437$Wr6.2721@newssvr23.news.prodigy.com> > > What a surprise, Mr. Faux-food eating fat boy. Weren't you > just telling me you knew all the secrets to weight loss? Yes > you were. Too bad for you. There are secrets?
> Oh yeah, I guess I shouldn't say anything or else you'll > get your feelings hurt and threaten to leave the group > again like the drama queen that you are. I thought Bear was one of your supporters. I do have to pay closer attention.
JC Der Koenig - 06 Mar 2004 11:22 GMT > > From: JC Der Koenig (Thu, 04 Mar 2004 02:10:52 GMT) > > MsgId: <Mew1c.7437$Wr6.2721@newssvr23.news.prodigy.com> [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > I thought Bear was one of your supporters. I do have to pay closer > attention. You thought?
Well, thanks for trying anyway.
Kathy - 04 Mar 2004 02:15 GMT > I've been on this plateau since my initial 2 weeks on induction. I've never > had this happen to me. Other diets and plans were hard to stick with but I [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > Highest weight 353 > http://home.earthlink.net/~polarbear50/index.html I know how frustrated you are feeling right now. I have been stalled since August. I gain a few, then lose a few. Always the same three pounds. Sometimes I can't stand to get on that scale in the morning, but I torture myself anyway. Although the scale doesn't show any weight loss, my clothes are fitting better, and I feel so much better than when I was on weight watchers (which I am a life time member who did not maintain the weight loss for more than 6 months).
Your weight loss is GREAT so far and it will pay off in the end!
It is a WOL and a WOE for life and not just a diet. The end result will eventually come but you will experience stalls along the way. Just stick with LC if it makes you feel good.
Kathy LC since 3/17/02
|
|
|