Can you eat too much of one thing on weight watchers or as long as you stick
within your points does it not matter ?
I love sandwiches and sometimes think I could eat just those in a day.
Weight watchers say as long as you stay within your points you will lose
weight, but surely there must be more to it than that ? Im sure if I ate 20
slices of bread in a day I wouldnt lose weight although it would strictly be
within my points. I know people would say that this wouldnt give me all the
vitamins I need but you could also eat vegetables and vitamin supplements.
Does anyone find if they eat too much of any one thing that they struggle to
lose ?
One thing that also makes me wonder is this. I used to be on slimming world
and according to their plan I could eat as much pasta, rice, noodles,
potatoes etc as I wanted on a green day. However on weight watchers a pack
of super noodles I believe is 9 points. So while slimming world was saying I
could eat as many noodles as I wanted and I did eat a lot ( maybe 2 packs at
dinner and 2 as a late snack as well as a main meal ) weight watchers is
saying eat 2 packs a day and you can kiss you allowance goodbye. Eat 4 as I
was doing and I would gain.
???
Laura - 24 Feb 2005 03:16 GMT
I think everybody is different. I know of people that lose while staying
within their points having the same foods day after day.
Others, like me, need to keep their metabolism guessing by varying their
meals. When I get into a rut and have cereal for breakfast or salads for
lunch every day I stop losing. Once I shake things up a little I start
losing again.
On Slimming World the green, red, etc days automatically built the variety
in to your menus. I suspect that this plan also encouraged low, medium, high
and super high calorie days as a way of keeping your metabolism going.
Something like the wendie plan. So you could eat those multiple packs of
noodles because on other days you were eating low calorie foods as a way of
balancing out the high cal days. Does this make sense?
> Can you eat too much of one thing on weight watchers or as long as you stick
> within your points does it not matter ?
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
>
> ???
wafflycat - 24 Feb 2005 08:35 GMT
> Can you eat too much of one thing on weight watchers or as long as you
> stick
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> the
> vitamins I need but you could also eat vegetables and vitamin supplements.
On the theory that as long as calories in are less than calories out, you
will lose weight, then you could eat your entire points allowance in junk
food and you'll lose weight. Not exactly the healthy way to do it though :-)
Much better to choose healthy options and have a variety of foods if for no
other reason than variety is the spice of life and will help a person retain
interest so be easier to stay on track.
> Does anyone find if they eat too much of any one thing that they struggle
> to
> lose ?
I find if I eat a lot of one thing it's easier to become bored with it.
> One thing that also makes me wonder is this. I used to be on slimming
> world
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> I
> was doing and I would gain.
There's noodles and there's noodles. Not all noodles are equal in this
world. Some noodles are just that - noodles with nothing added. It's up to
you to add what you want for interest & flavour. You can add lots of yummy
healthy stuff that is flavoursome. BUT - buy something like Pot Noodles and
look at the ingredient list - salt will be in there and remember that salt
as given on the label you have to multiply to get the true level (is it by
4.2???) Alkso there's likely some fat added and lots of flavourings... Those
type of noodles should be consigned to the rubbish bin IMHO.
Cheers, helen s
> ???
Anna H. - 24 Feb 2005 09:51 GMT
Hi,
>Can you eat too much of one thing on weight watchers or as long as you stick
>within your points does it not matter ?
It can be difficult switching from one plan to another. My advice is to
forget what you learned with Slimming World and just concentrate on WWs.
I think my main problem with programs like SW is that IMHO, it doesn't
really teach you good healthy eating habits. Sometimes WW's isn't so
great either, depending on your leader, typified by questions like this.
There are two things WWs attempts to enable us to do:
1. Eat fewer calories than we burn off to enable you to lose weight.
2. Encourage healthy eating ie. Low fat, high fibre, plenty of fruit
and veg, small quantities of good quality protein foods etc.
In my experience, until I changed my eating habits and learned to make
healthier choices, I couldn't keep the weight off long-term, although
initially I could lose a lot of weight simply by sticking to a very
boring diet. That is how diets like the Cabbage Soup Diet worked, after
all, and many people have accused the Atkins Diet of the same.
The other issue is that a good variety ensures you get all the minerals,
vitamins, fatty acids and other nutrients you need for good health and
plenty of energy. By sticking to one type of food you are risking
significant nutritional deficiencies, for instance, wholemeal bread
contains protein, but the body can only use that protein if it also has
the proteins from peas and beans. Beans on toast might therefore be
thought of as a perfectly balanced meal, but of course it's high in salt
and deficient in iron, vitamin C, vitamins D and E and essential fatty
acids. White bread is even worse - it's basically just starch, which is
OK as a fast energy source, but that's about it. And of course, "Energy"
is just another way of saying "Calories".
Personally, I wouldn't touch so-called "Super Noodles" with a 10 foot
barge pool. Have you read the ingredients and nutritional information
recently? Stuffed full of saturated fats and additives. A friend of mine
and I were looking at them recently (she's switched from SW to WW's
recently too - in fact, I thought you were her!). If you like noodles,
try ordinary Sharwoods Egg Noodles, and add your own Chinese-style
vegetables and maybe a few prawns, some Quorn or chicken. Amazingly
healthy and delicious.
Good luck - I'm sure you'll find WWs a lot easier to fit into everyday
life and I wish you the best.

Signature
Anna (in UK)
Start Weight: 174 lbs
Goal Weight: 146 lbs
Current Weight: 163 lbs
"The revolutionary new diet pill that turns body fat into Rolex watches" -
Dilbert Online
wafflycat - 24 Feb 2005 10:06 GMT
> Hi,
>>Can you eat too much of one thing on weight watchers or as long as you
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
> diet. That is how diets like the Cabbage Soup Diet worked, after all, and
> many people have accused the Atkins Diet of the same.
When I did WW back in the very early 90s, I got to goal & kept the weight of
for several years. WW back then was called "personal choice" and you had to
have *minimum* quantities of various food groups each day. The way WW broke
it down was milk, fat, protein, vegetables, bread & fruit. If you followed
the proportions of each category on a daily basis, you automatically
followed a healthy, balanced diet. You coudl have extras of the good stuff
(floaters) and the naughties (optional calories) and there were different
levels (1, 2 & 3) each giving a different total calorie intake for the day,
but all giving a healthy, balanced diet. Included in it were excellent
guidelines such as no more than 7 eggs per week, no more than 12 ounces of
red meat per week and no more than 4 of cheese per week (unless very low-fat
such as cottage cheese). Following the above, I *never* felt hungry and I
got to goal easily and maintained easily. I'm following the same principles
now, in effect, when I point my food and make food choices. It taught the
principles of healthy eating, having a balanced diet and one full of
variety. Something I think seems to have less emphasis in WW these days.
Cheers, helen s
ray miller - 24 Feb 2005 19:02 GMT
>Can you eat too much of one thing on weight watchers or as long as you stick
>within your points does it not matter ?
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
>saying eat 2 packs a day and you can kiss you allowance goodbye. Eat 4 as I
>was doing and I would gain.
so far as calories are concerned a calorie is a calorie and it doesn't
matter where it comes from. If you eat 2000 calories of bread it has
the same potential to put weight on or not as 2000 calories of
protein.
However what you eat will definately affect your metabolism, so it
really depends what you are comfortable with, and of course you should
be getting the right micronutrients etc.
Ray

Signature
2002 1.8i eternal red