I'm a M/ 5'4/ 180 lbs. and I need to get to 140 or about.The
problem is that after a 15 lb. weight loss,I can't budge the scales.
I'm beginning to think that height has something to do with the
ability to lose weight.
All my taller friends and some family members are on the same high
pro.-low carb program and they are all successful.
Am I way off on this theory and ,if so,what do you think is the
problem?
Thanks in advance,
L.C.
Anna Hayward - 29 Jun 2003 10:44 GMT
Hi LC,
> I'm a M/ 5'4/ 180 lbs. and I need to get to 140 or about.The
>problem is that after a 15 lb. weight loss,I can't budge the scales.
What are you doing to lose the weight? This is a Weight-Watchers group
and I know that following the WWs plan, it would be very unusual to
plateau like that after losing 15lbs.
If you've been following a low cal diet it is possible you're eating too
little - this is the typical pattern with very low cal diets. You
initially lose well but then your metabolism drops to a snails pace and
you stop losing.
> I'm beginning to think that height has something to do with the
>ability to lose weight.
>All my taller friends and some family members are on the same high
>pro.-low carb program and they are all successful.
You mean something like Atkins? That doesn't suit everybody - many
people are on this group because low carbing didn't work for them.
Instead, we use a system that relies on learning appropriate portion
sizes, cutting the fat and increasing the fibre, fruit and veg and
learning a better way of eating that hopefully we can stick to for life.
Oh, and the great thing is you can eat anything you like - provided you
control the portions.
> Am I way off on this theory and ,if so,what do you think is the
>problem?
There is evidence that low carbing works like every other diet - by
cutting your calories. The fact is that most people can't eat sufficient
protein and fat foods alone to get fat. But some people *can* and
they're the ones for whom the total lack of portion control doesn't
work. Other people end up doing the opposite: eating so few calories
that their metabolism crashes.
Either way, neither group is learning how to control their portion sizes
for life, they are depriving themselves of a major food group (which
means they won't be able to stick to it for long) and I cannot see how
it's possible to eat the recommended amounts of fruit and veg (minimum 5
a day) and stick to a low-carb diet. Not to mention the fact that most
medical authorities believe complex carbohydrates (wholegrains etc.)
should be the main energy source in the diet.
YMMV, but you may want to look into the WWs way of doing things and see
if that works better for you. It certainly worked well for a lot of us!
;o)

Signature
Anna Hayward, Email: alienvisitorATratbagDOTdemonDOTcoDOTuk
(184)176/now 151/goal 142
Started WW (online) 21/03/03 at 176 lbs
IFFC goal: 155 lbs (achieved 13 June 2003)
IFFC (Independence from Food Challenge):
http://www.ratbag.demon.co.uk/anna/IFFC/
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"A life lived in fear is a life half lived" - from the movie "Strictly Ballroom"
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Elaine Kirkham - 29 Jun 2003 18:39 GMT
It doesn't sound like you are following the WW program. Why don't you try
it!
Elaine K
331.4/186.4/179
> I'm a M/ 5'4/ 180 lbs. and I need to get to 140 or about.The
> problem is that after a 15 lb. weight loss,I can't budge the scales.
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> Thanks in advance,
> L.C.
Heather - 29 Jun 2003 23:30 GMT
> I'm a M/ 5'4/ 180 lbs. and I need to get to 140 or about.The
> problem is that after a 15 lb. weight loss,I can't budge the scales.
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> Thanks in advance,
> L.C.
I think what Anna wrote is spot on. It could be that you're not eating
enough, so your metabolism has slowed down. I don't think that height
plays much of a role, if any. Try getting involved in Weight Watchers,
and see how that works for you. It's working very well for most of us
:)
Good luck,
Heather
Angela Woollcombe - 30 Jun 2003 01:10 GMT
hey l cantrell
i am the same height as u and i had the same problem as u for awhile i
couldn't lose weight. i stayed at 140 lbs for almost eternity or at least
thats what it seemed like. but i started losing again. the more weight that
u lose if u are following ww u have to drop ur points also make sure that u
are drinking plenty of water. and maybe u need to add more exercise. but
whatever u do don't give up everybody hits a platue. just keep working at it
and u'll start losing sooner then u think.
keep up the good work and don't give up.
take care angie
> I'm a M/ 5'4/ 180 lbs. and I need to get to 140 or about.The
> problem is that after a 15 lb. weight loss,I can't budge the scales.
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> Thanks in advance,
> L.C.