Weight Loss Forum / WeightWatchers / February 2007
I'm sure this question has been asked.. But: Does it really work?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Ivan - 22 Feb 2007 01:16 GMT Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. Which was great, really. I weighed and measured myself, and kept track of everything I ate during the day. Today is day 2, and going well so far..
The only thing that bothers me is how expensive everything is.. Sure, I don't have to buy the WW meals.. But often when I cook I tend to have trouble with portion sizes..
Does anyone have any tips in regards to this?
I'm really looking forward (granted, with skeptisism) to discovering my weight next week.. The reason why I'm skeptical is because yesterday, after eating 18 points, I felt like I've eaten more than I normally do.. And that was only 18 points.. Considering my height and weight and level of activity, I should be eating 26-29 points!!
I won't be going to the meetings for now.. Mainly because of lack of time, though mostly because of money issues.. I'll stick to counting my own points and using the support of my girlfriend..
I'm 6'1" and my weight at the moment is 250lbs. Waist is 44 inches.
I will report next week with my new measurements, as well as an updated report of how I feel about WW.
In the mean time, if someone could please tell me how to avoid having to purchase WW food (or any other frozen meals).. It'd be fantastic.
Drachen - 22 Feb 2007 04:55 GMT purchase a scale!!! I highly recommend it... 3 oz of chicken is a lot more than you'd think but cheese is sooooo small in portion... but works for a quick snack...
I have to consume 35 points... sigh... and sometimes it is hard to do and sometimes its wayyyyy too easy... one chocolate bar will zoom me right up there...*G*
I'd also recommend going to at least one or two meetings at least, most places allow a freebie if you haven't joined yet...
and a good investment is also a good book that lists brand names, calories/fibre/etc for various foods... and use your fiber calculator to get your point value, if you've joined you'll get one... very handy for shopping...
also, I would also HIGHLY recommend the guide for eating out, as they list a lot of popular quickly places and places that are frequented a lot, etc... a&w, arbys dennys, dq... etc... it also helps to eye out points and size of servings I've found...
I rarely purchase frozen meals... I find its never satisfying enough... I'd rather make my own then freeze the portions... *see 'meal planning' subject in this newsgroup*...
I've lost a few pounds, but I only track about 4 days a week... the rest I guess at really... but it is working... if I don't track I don't lose... I track I lose... I'm on day three of four right now for tracking... I totally ignored monday... but did extra workout on tuesday to attempt to make up for that...
and I'm pretty busy and have lots of obligations to do as well... but I set aside one day *morning really* to go to weight watchers, then out for breakfast...* its a total of 25$ for the day... so 100$/month... give or take pending on what I have for breakfast of course... and the support of people who have 'been there' is awesome!!! and really helps... regardless if you gain or lose its always good to talk about it.
> Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. > I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > In the mean time, if someone could please tell me how to avoid having > to purchase WW food (or any other frozen meals).. It'd be fantastic. Stormmee - 24 Feb 2007 15:13 GMT good advice, Lee
> purchase a scale!!! I highly recommend it... 3 oz of chicken is a lot more > than you'd think but cheese is sooooo small in portion... but works for a [quoted text clipped - 66 lines] > > In the mean time, if someone could please tell me how to avoid having > > to purchase WW food (or any other frozen meals).. It'd be fantastic. Willow Herself - 22 Feb 2007 06:19 GMT 6'1 and 250 lbs... if you're eating only 18 points your going directly toward disaster..
Will~
> Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. > I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > In the mean time, if someone could please tell me how to avoid having > to purchase WW food (or any other frozen meals).. It'd be fantastic. Teri - 22 Feb 2007 11:57 GMT > Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. > I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > Sure, I don't have to buy the WW meals.. But often when I cook I tend > to have trouble with portion sizes.. I bought a ww cookbook in costco and made 2 recipes from it ( I bought it 3 days ago!!). My husband raved about the first recipe and it wasn't too hard to portion (servings made = 4, split recipe in quarters and don't come back for seconds :-) and was fairly simple to make. Yesterday I made a manhattan clam chowder (ww recipe) in the crockpot and 1 1/2 c = 2 points, so I allowed myself 2 full cups. I, too, need to invest in a scale for food. Teri
ahmward - 22 Feb 2007 16:27 GMT I just bought that cookbook for my daughter. I've used it for the past six months and enjoy many recipes. I rarely use WW foods or frozen meals as I like to do my own cooking. What is nice about these new cookbooks is that the food is flavorful and much better in many ways than the recipes in standard cookbook.
I use my Salter scale all the time. Even if a package says one ounce equals x amount of items, I prefer to weigh the one ounce. It also helps me if I am using leftovers. For example a chicken breast may weigh 5-6 ounces but for lunch I want no more than 3 so the scale is invaluable.
Audrey
>> Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. >> I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > too, need to invest in a scale for food. > Teri Teri - 22 Feb 2007 19:53 GMT >I just bought that cookbook for my daughter. I've used it for the past six >months and enjoy many recipes. I rarely use WW foods or frozen meals as I [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > > Audrey I just bought a Salter scale ... stainless steel. Do you weigh the meat before or after you cook it (does it even matter that much?). From that cookbook I made chicken breasts w/broccoli rabe, raddicchio, onions garlic and spinach fettucine... which was just out of this world ... even my 8yo scarfed it down. Teri
greenbanks - 22 Feb 2007 20:21 GMT > I just bought a Salter scale ... stainless steel. Do you weigh the meat > before or after you cook it (does it even matter that much?). From that > cookbook I made chicken breasts w/broccoli rabe, raddicchio, onions garlic > and spinach fettucine... which was just out of this world ... even my 8yo > scarfed it down. > Teri Definitely after. You're cooking off some of the fat, even in lean meats. You'll enjoy the control you get with a scale.
 Signature M'Lou
Willow Herself - 22 Feb 2007 20:30 GMT When I make things like stews, or casserole (where I won't be picking out the meat cubes to weigh them!!) I weigh the food ahead and take out about 1/4 of the weight. That's about what meat loses as it cooks. Will~
>> I just bought a Salter scale ... stainless steel. Do you weigh the meat >> before or after you cook it (does it even matter that much?). From that [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > Definitely after. You're cooking off some of the fat, even in lean meats. > You'll enjoy the control you get with a scale. Drachen - 22 Feb 2007 23:13 GMT unless you go for bison, which is heartier in flavour, and almost zero fat...
but if you're making a stew, wouldn't the juices and fat remain within the stew? therefore wouln'dt not taking out 1/4 of the weight be detrimental to the overall amount?
I've also found that if I roast the beef or bison beforehand in the oven, its a lot tender and tastier in the stews... you could also roast the potatoes and carrots all together, then just cut them up with your onions garlic and other veggies to simmer for a short bit...
> When I make things like stews, or casserole (where I won't be picking out > the meat cubes to weigh them!!) I weigh the food ahead and take out about [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > > -- > > M'Lou Willow Herself - 22 Feb 2007 23:37 GMT I'd never make a beef stew without browning the beef first.
> unless you go for bison, which is heartier in flavour, and almost zero > fat... [quoted text clipped - 29 lines] >> > -- >> > M'Lou Stormmee - 24 Feb 2007 15:18 GMT the bison like the venison I eat still shrinks even though the fat content is reduced, and WW has before cooked weights as well as cooked on the database, I use those when making stews, Lee
> unless you go for bison, which is heartier in flavour, and almost zero > fat... [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > > > -- > > > M'Lou Stormmee - 24 Feb 2007 15:15 GMT my scale is my second best helper on WW, Lee
> > Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. > > I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > allowed myself 2 full cups. I, too, need to invest in a scale for food. > Teri Laura - 22 Feb 2007 13:34 GMT For starters, invest in a good food scale and a set of measuring cups and spoons. If you aren't weighing and measuring you probably under estimated your points for the day. At your height/weight, 18 points would mean you were starving. I aim for 20 day and some days it is not enough food for me. I'm 5'3 and 153 lbs.
As for shopping, WW does not have to be expensive. You need to shop wisely.I get chicken breasts (look for sales), pork chops, frozen fish, cereal, oatmeal, egg beaters, skim milk, lots of fresh/frozen veggies & fruits, bagged salad/spinich, lean hamburger meat, tuna, eggs (rest of family), boca burgers, potato rolls and soups. I may be spending more at the grocery store but on healthy items. We have drastically reduced the number of times we eat out so we save money that way. We don't buy many chips, crackers and other junk anymore. I do buy WW smart ones and Amy's Organic bowls for quick meals to have in the freezer for nights that I have a meeting or DH/DD are having something I don't want to eat. I also only buy them when they are on sale. Last night DD wanted lasgagne. They had stoffers and I had a smart one. Unfortunately it was not that satisfying so I probably won't buy that one again. DH did not plan the meal very well or I would have insisted that he add a veggie to mine to make it more satisfying. They are okay for lunch but not for dinner (ymmv). I usually buy the ones labeled "smart about carbs" as they are lower in points and don't have rice, pasta or potato in them. These have more protein than the ones where the points are mostly from carbs.
You probably should find a WW book to help you with the basic point values of foods. eBay has the old kits available. Another good source is Dottie's weightloss zone: http://www.dottisweightlosszone.com/index.html. Scroll down to the bottom of her home page and you will see links to restaurant and food lists. Print these up to create a reference book for yourself. You'll do fine. Having your GF support you is great too. DH only semi supports me and it is very frustrating at times but that's a story for another day.
> Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. > I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > In the mean time, if someone could please tell me how to avoid having > to purchase WW food (or any other frozen meals).. It'd be fantastic. Ivan - 23 Feb 2007 02:05 GMT Hi all.. And wow, thanks so much for all your replies!!
Okay.. Yes, I'm 6'1" and weigh 250.. On the first day I couldn't eat more than 18 points.. Second day I managed to go up to 21.. I do have a WW book, one that lists all the points for different food items, including competitor's brands.. Which has really helped out, especially when eating things like vegetables and fruits..
But will the diet not work for me because I'm under eating? I work in IT, and thus do not move around too much during the day.. Which is probably why I'm rarely hungry.. I will start walking during the week.. Although I've said that in the past and never have..
I'll be investing on a food scale as some of you suggested, and will definately try to start cooking.. I love cooking, but never really been a big fan of measuring .. I normally cook by 'feel', and hate measuring. Perhaps a habit I should get used to.
It seems like there is a great support group in this NG, so I will definately be coming back in to ask for advise when needed..
I will see if I can get a cook book. The other day, funnily enough the day after I started WW, at the train station they were giving out WW stuff.. I got a bag with WW chocolate mousse, a WW protein bar, breakfast cereal, a box of skim milk.. What else.. Ooh, and a WW magazine!! The mag had lots of really good recipes, so I will read through it and perhaps make something up tonight.
I'll let you know how it goes.
Ooh, and also, does anyone know how lean kangaroo meat is, in comparison to beef?
Cheers,
Ivan.
Laura - 23 Feb 2007 02:24 GMT Where do you live that you have kangaroo meat? I'm guessing you are not in the USA. The points in the WW materials are for US nutritional info. Maybe that's why you only counted 18 points. Can you post your menu for the 2 days so we can see what you are eating?
> Hi all.. > And wow, thanks so much for all your replies!! [quoted text clipped - 35 lines] > > Ivan. Willow Herself - 23 Feb 2007 03:06 GMT If he's in Kangaroo land.. maybe he got the Kangaroo land material right?
Will~
> Where do you live that you have kangaroo meat? I'm guessing you are not in > the USA. The points in the WW materials are for US nutritional info. Maybe [quoted text clipped - 40 lines] >> >> Ivan. Ivan - 23 Feb 2007 03:48 GMT > Where do you live that you have kangaroo meat? I'm guessing you are not in > the USA. The points in the WW materials are for US nutritional info. Maybe > that's why you only counted 18 points. Can you post your menu for the 2 days > so we can see what you are eating? I am, in fact, in Australia -- hence the availability of Kanga-meat. Not that I'm a big fan, but I heard that it is extremly lean.
I left my book at home today, but from memory, this is what I ate:
Breakfast Bowl of WW cereal (one serving) and soy milk (1/2 cup) (4 1/2 points) Black Coffee
Mid-morning snack WW Peaches (1/2 point) Black Coffee
Lunch WW frozen meal -- Beef hot pot (I can't remember, but think it was 3 1/2) Two WW choc-chip cookies (1 point) Black Coffee
Afternoon snack WW Peaches (1/2 point) Black Coffee
Dinner WW Beef lasagne (again, can't remember, but believe it was 5 points) 2 glasses of red wine (I think 3 points)
Dessert 1 cup canterlope (1/2 point) WW Jello (0) Black Coffee
Ivan - 23 Feb 2007 04:14 GMT Oh, and today..
This is today's menu, as I can remember it better than the day of 18.
Breakfast: Two weetbix hi-bran + 1 cup soy milk ( 5 points )
In between: Box of V8 vegetable juice. (1 1/2 points)
Morning snack: Two choc-chip WW cookies ( 1 point) Black Coffee
Lunch: Tuna Sandwitch (white bread, can of WW tuna, alfalfa sprouts and tomato) (not sure how many points that is. I'm thinking around 5.) Black Coffee
Nothing else yet.
Not sure about dinner. I will attempt at cooking something, as I'm having my folks over.
Stormmee - 24 Feb 2007 15:35 GMT good for you, Lee
> Oh, and today.. > [quoted text clipped - 19 lines] > Not sure about dinner. I will attempt at cooking something, as I'm > having my folks over. Laura - 23 Feb 2007 13:26 GMT That's not a lot of food and it looks like you are on a diet. I would be starving for sure on this menu. You want to aim for a lifestyle change that gives you variety and a nice balance of foods.
I can't tell which set of points you are using. In the US point system most servings of fruit are 1 point and the wine is 2pts per 4oz. The difference in point systems in other countries relates to how the nutrition info is listed on the packages. Some countries (England?) don't list cal/fat/fiber like they do in the US so they get a different number of points to compensate for that. I don't know about the Aussie nutritional info.
You are missing veggies, oils and dairy. Take a look at this page on the 8 healthy guidelines. http://www.weightwatchers.com/util/art/index_art.aspx?tabnum=1&art_id=21901
Following this will give you the much needed points to properly fuel your body. As Willow said, you'll get results for a while but then get sick and/or stop losing. Some also gain weight because your body holds on to all of calories consumed. Not a good cycle to get into. You also lose muscle instead of fat when you starve yourself.
How much water are you drinking? It looks like you drink a fair amount of coffee.
Here's a WW eating guide that they published a few years ago. It's aimed at 20 (US) pts per day so just increase your portion sizes or # of choices per column to get to your min required daily point value. It has 3 different eating plans: high carb, high protein and mixed. Pick the one you like for the day and select away. http://www.weightwatchers.com/downloads/1033/Util/art/EatingGuide.pdf
>> Where do you live that you have kangaroo meat? I'm guessing you are not >> in [quoted text clipped - 35 lines] > WW Jello (0) > Black Coffee Stormmee - 24 Feb 2007 15:34 GMT that sounds a good balance if a bit short on vegetables... you can cut that food budget by getting a different brand of peaches and pointing them from your calculator... go and shop for the best nutrition/point value per serving... then get that to about 2 or 3 choices, then shop for money value from the better nutrition choices, Lee
> > Where do you live that you have kangaroo meat? I'm guessing you are not in > > the USA. The points in the WW materials are for US nutritional info. Maybe [quoted text clipped - 32 lines] > WW Jello (0) > Black Coffee Willow Herself - 23 Feb 2007 03:05 GMT The diet will work at first, then stop working, then you'll get sick...
Will~
> Hi all.. > And wow, thanks so much for all your replies!! [quoted text clipped - 35 lines] > > Ivan. Stormmee - 24 Feb 2007 15:30 GMT I think it is lean but am not sure. glad we can help... as to the points I have to eat every one of mine, others do not, this is a thing you must learn for your own body... and there is another tip for you to keep in mind... you did not fail if you don't lose, what you have done is given yourself a lesson of how to eat better, if you gained you can review your food journal and figure out why... also watch your weight loss pattern as after about eight weeks or so you will see a pattern that is there, again good luck, Lee
> Hi all.. > And wow, thanks so much for all your replies!! [quoted text clipped - 35 lines] > > Ivan. Stormmee - 24 Feb 2007 15:11 GMT we rarely buy those, you need to look at fresh meat and frozen vegetables, if you shop sale items and you aren't buying as much junk food you should save money. good for you starting, Lee
> Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. > I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > In the mean time, if someone could please tell me how to avoid having > to purchase WW food (or any other frozen meals).. It'd be fantastic. Ivan - 25 Feb 2007 23:15 GMT Hi all, and thanks again for all your replies and helpful advise..
I went to a birthday party on Saturday evening and thought I had blown it by eating what I did.. I did keep to one plate, and tried getting things that I knew I wouldn't regret getting, such as chicken instead of pork, no gravy, greens and cous cous instead of pasta salads, fruit for dessert instead of cake..
I didn't really count the points of the food I ate, but I did note them down and guestimated about 17 points. I think I ate a total of about 28 points that day. Much more than any other day I've had since started the diet.
The next day (yesterday), I grilled out chicken and again, had lots of fats and oils with roasted veggies (potatoes and the like)..
And today, I thought to myself, surely I must have put on some weight over the weekend..
So I measured myself, and compared it to when I originated the diet..
Albeit the change not being big, I did shrink by half a centimeter!! Which, was surprising, really, as the third day into the diet I had gained a centimeter from when I measured myself originally..
Overall, a 1.5 cm loss (or half an inch) in less than a week..
Could have been water, of course, but still.. The change is welcomed and makes me feel good. so I'll take it. :)
Stormmee - 25 Feb 2007 23:25 GMT and the small changes to others that may have seen your plate are huge changes for you, and if you keep to that philosophy you will do fine, good for you!!! Lee
> Hi all, and thanks again for all your replies and helpful advise.. > [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] > Could have been water, of course, but still.. The change is welcomed > and makes me feel good. so I'll take it. :) Gary G - 26 Feb 2007 18:28 GMT Don't be lulled into believing that you can continue to go overboard for long...Loss and gain is not always reflected by the scale...As many here will tell you...I spent the last 2 weeks ratcheting up my walking to almost 8 miles a day and showed a weight loss of .02 Lb Granted I'm close to goal and possibly I'm building up muscle...For me over the last year or so I've had many events or situations which caused me to overdue it...Sometimes planned sometimes not but I always wake the next day and continue on my journey towards my goal...I certainly don't want to preach but beware of constant falls from the wagon it a recipe for disaster in my humble opinion...Good luck in your journey...GG
> Hi all, and thanks again for all your replies and helpful advise.. > [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] > Could have been water, of course, but still.. The change is welcomed > and makes me feel good. so I'll take it. :) lowridermac - 26 Feb 2007 20:29 GMT Walking or similar will make every diet work even better. ------------------------------ How To Solve Your Problem Now! http://www.Netvoters.com
Kate XXXXXX - 27 Feb 2007 23:59 GMT > Okay.. So I started the WW diet yesterday.. > I consumed 18 points and felt so full I could not eat another bite.. > Which was great, really. No, not really... You need to eat almost all those points to lose in a healthy way. Don't go too lean and mean! cut out a little volume stuff, and save a little treat for the end of the day...
> I weighed and measured myself, and kept track of everything I ate > during the day. > Today is day 2, and going well so far.. Don't weigh and measure every day! Pick a time and weigh once a week, at that time and never in between! That way madness lies... Weight naturally fluctuates from day to day, so keep a once a week score only.
> The only thing that bothers me is how expensive everything is.. Cooking for yourself is a LOT cheaper than buying ready meals!
> Sure, I don't have to buy the WW meals.. But often when I cook I tend > to have trouble with portion sizes.. Weigh everything. Look at the guides in the books if you can... For example, a portion of fillet steak is a steak the size of a pack of cards, a baked jacket potato should be about the size of a standard light bulb, a portion of full fat cheese is the size of a standard box of matches... 2 oz of uncooked rice is a single portion.
> Does anyone have any tips in regards to this? If you don't have any kitchen scales, get some. The WW scales can help you point everything you eat as you weigh it. And follow some WW recipes, paying attention to the number of portions the recipe serves. If it serves 4, portion it out and freeze the un-eaten portions in single portion packs for other days...
> I'm really looking forward (granted, with skeptisism) to discovering > my weight next week.. You'll lose if you steer it right! not every week, but you'll get there! :)
> The reason why I'm skeptical is because yesterday, after eating 18 > points, I felt like I've eaten more than I normally do.. And that was > only 18 points.. Considering my height and weight and level of > activity, I should be eating 26-29 points!! See my comment above. I bet you packed yourself full of zero point veggies or something, leaving less room for the proteins you also need to do this right.
> I won't be going to the meetings for now.. Mainly because of lack of > time, though mostly because of money issues.. I'll stick to counting [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > In the mean time, if someone could please tell me how to avoid having > to purchase WW food (or any other frozen meals).. It'd be fantastic. Buy some WW cook books and learn to cook your own WW meals! Many can be frozen for later, so on days you have time, cook for the days you don't! :)
 Signature Kate XXXXXX R.C.T.Q Madame Chef des Trolls Lady Catherine, Wardrobe Mistress of the Chocolate Buttons http://www.katedicey.co.uk Click on Kate's Pages and explore!
|
|
|