Weight Loss Forum / General Topics / May 2007
Whey Protein In Addition to Glutamine and BCAA???
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Prisoner at War - 03 May 2007 15:51 GMT I'm thinking about trying out supplementation because I don't seem to be progressing. The main culprit seems to be (so-called? I'm still skeptical) "overtraining," but since I'm not young like I used to be, perhaps it finally exists for me, too (I'm still wedded to the ol' Army idea of rigorous cardio 2x daily, etc.). So I'm looking into supplements to see if that helps any -- for example, I'm looking into testosterone boosters to see if that helps restore the "biochemical context" of my younger self, with respect to work-outs and progress.
Researching the matter, there appears to be a million-and-one ingredients necessary to optimal performance and growth, LOL. But a few seem to consistently stand out. Like, first of all, protein. Then creatine and glutamine and BCAAs...but aren't all these "-ines" proteins?? It seems pure whey protein powders already contain glutamine and BCAAs. So why are those two latter ingredients also sold separately???
bcince@gmail.com - 03 May 2007 16:25 GMT > I'm thinking about trying out supplementation because I don't seem to > be progressing. The main culprit seems to be (so-called? I'm still [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > glutamine and BCAAs. So why are those two latter ingredients also > sold separately??? Make Lots of Money Quick, Easy & LEGAL with Paypal
AS SEEN ON OPRAH!!
PAYPAL VERIFIES THAT THIS $6 INVESTMENT SCHEME IS 100% LEGAL AND IS A BIG HIT THIS YEAR SEE
THEIR NOTE BELOW OR ASK THEM DIRECTLY... THIS SCHEME MIGHT TAKE 15-30 MINUTES AND JUST $6,
BUT IT IS 100% WORTH IT TO MAKE THOUSANDS SO QUICKLY. THIS IS NOT ANOTHER SCAM THAT TAKES LOTS OF YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY; THIS IS A NO RISK INVESTMENT THAT WILL MAKE YOU
THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS VERY EASILY AND QUICKLY.
>From PayPal: "Dear Member, it has come to our attention that there is a PayPal scheme floating around at the moment you may have heard or seen the $6 scheme. You may have even taken part in it well we have been asked a lot of questions about this scheme the answer is yes it does work and yes it is safe to use providing you follow the rules it is legal and has made a big hit on the internet this year. If you would like to take part in this scheme or would like a bit more information then please see the attached file that was kindly donated to us. Thank you for using PayPal!"
Get rid of student loans, get out of debt, make money to go traveling!!
Making Money - This Really Works Keep in mind that everything stated below is 100% legal as stated by the U.S. Post Office (1-800-725-2161). A little while back, I was browsing through newsgroups, just like you are now, and came across an article similar to this that said you could make thousands of pounds within weeks with only an initial investment of $6.00! : Anyway it said that you have to send $1.00 to each of the following names on the list, stated at the end of this article using Paypal. You don't have to be preferred or verified to transfer and receive money, so you lose no money through transfers. Now honestly, what is six pounds, especially out of a Paypal account. In exchange you will make thousands in the first few months. You then place your own name and email address in the bottom of the list at #6, and post the article in at least 200 newsgroups. (There are thousands of newsgroups) No catch, that was it. So after thinking it over, and talking to a few people first, I thought about trying it.
I know that you have seen this on Oprah or even received numerous messages about this simple program and have probably just deleted them, I know I have! But for some unknown reason this time I decided to give it a try.
Please give it an honest effort, you will not be disappointed and will be very glad you did when it starts to work. Remember, all you're going to be out of pocket is about the cost of a couple of coffees with the opportunity of banking thousands of pounds into your PayPal account!
I sent out my measly $6.00 to the six people on the list. Well GUESS WHAT!!... Within 7 days, I started: getting $$$$$ in my account! I was shocked! I figured it would end soon, but the CASH just kept coming in. In my first week, I made about $25.00. By the end of the second week I had made a total of over $1,000.00! In the third week I had over $15,060.00 and it's still growing. This is now my fourth week and I have made a total of just over $26,000.00 and it's still coming in rapidly. It's certainly worth $6.00 and 6 minutes to send it out. This program WORKS, all you have to do is try it, and waste some pocket change. You could find six dollar lying around the house. There is absolutely nothing you could lose. Just follow the 3 basic steps below to make thousands in just a few days, weeks, or months, it all depends on how many posts of this letter you put in message boards or send as emails.
Here's how it works: When you post 200 messages all over the internet, it is estimated that at least 15 people will respond and send you a $1.00. ($15.00) Those 15 will Post 200 Posts each and 225 people send you $1.00 ($225.00) Those 225 people Post 200 Posts each and 3,375 people send you $1.00 ($3,375.00) Those 3,375 post 200 posts each and 759,375 people send you $1.00 ($759,375.00) At this point your name drops off the list, but so far you have received $813,615.00. Note: I'm not saying this is going to make everyone 800 grand, but lets say even 1 person out of 200 tries this program, you are still going to make 50,000 pounds anywhere from 1 month to 6 months max!!!!! You can also copy this letter and email it to some of your friends and associates, it's a guarantee that some of them will be interested and give it a go, the more that do the more you make.
INSTRUCTIONS 1. Immediately send $1.00 to each of the six people on the list using Paypal, and in the comment (Subject) section type "Please add me to your list". Below are the emails that you transfer the money into:
Paypal accounts to send 1 dollar to:
1) apple-intel-fan at hotmail.com 2) richardschoofs at mac.com 3) moomansion at moomansion.karoo.co.uk 4) aazzaad1 at yahoo.co.uk 5) salautom at hotmail.com 6) balcones183@hotmail.com
2.After sending the money to the first 6 people on the list, you can remove the name next to the #1 on the list and move the rest of the names up one position (#2 becomes #1, #3 becomes #2, etc?) Then place your name in the #6 position. Then save it.
3. When you have completed the instructions, take this letter and then go to (Google, Yahoo,...) and type in (Making Money Message board, Money Message Board, Money Forum, Free money Forum, or anything along those lines that are forums) and start posting your copy of this message at least 200 times, to as many unique message boards as you can, or more. The more times you post this at a unique board, the more money you will make. You can email your message to as many people you can but remember, the more you post and email the more money you make! Keep a copy of this letter so you can use it a second time. Post it out again in six months, but Post it with the addresses you receive with each pound. It will work better the second time. Estimates are at 20,000 to 50,000 new users, every day, with thousands of those joining the actual Internet. Remember, play FAIRLY and HONESTLY and this will work. If you don't have a paypal account you can copy the link below and follow the instructions. It's totally secure, costs you nothing to set- up and is a very useful way of transferring and more importantly receiving money. You will be amazed every time you check your account to see how much money has been paid into it, and this money goes straight in without any deductions. To sign up for Paypal follow this link, just make sure that you use the same email address for your paypall account that you put in this list, that's how your payments are made. www.paypal.com
4. This program remains successful because of the honesty and integrity of the participants. Please continue its success by carefully adhering to the instructions. In this business your product is not solid and tangible, it¹s a service. You are in the business of developing Mailing Lists. Many large corporations are happy to pay big bucks for quality lists. However, the money made from the mailing lists is secondary to the income which is made from people like you and me asking to be included in that list.
5. This is perfectly legal! If you have any doubts, refer to #####le 18 Sec. 1302 & 1241 of the Postal Lottery laws. Keep a copy of these steps for yourself and, whenever you need money, you can use it again and again. This is the biggest growing internet money making scheme on the net, you will see that as you post your letter to the message boards, but that just proves how successful it really is.
6. Good luck, don't forget to follow the instructions correctly and spend the money wisely!!
Steve Freides - 03 May 2007 17:00 GMT > I'm thinking about trying out supplementation because I don't seem to > be progressing. Please define what "progressing" would be for you.
> The main culprit seems to be (so-called? I'm still > skeptical) "overtraining," but since I'm not young like I used to be, > perhaps it finally exists for me, too (I'm still wedded to the ol' > Army idea of rigorous cardio 2x daily, etc.). Lots of cardio and getting bigger and/or stronger (what I assume you mean by "progressing") don't work well together for most people most of the time. Before changing your diet, try cutting back on the cardio.
Just my opinion.
-S- http://www.kbnj.com
> So I'm looking into > supplements to see if that helps any -- for example, I'm looking into [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > glutamine and BCAAs. So why are those two latter ingredients also > sold separately??? Prisoner at War - 03 May 2007 17:45 GMT > Please define what "progressing" would be for you. Well, I mean, not stuck at some particular weight -- like 275-lbs. on the bench press. I had done 315 at one time, for like two reps unassisted, and another one or two with some assist, and now 275 is my max.
I know numbers aren't everything, but they're an indicator, it seems. So I'm thinking it's probably old age setting in, loss of testosterone levels, whatever, and I'm now wondering if some supplementation is finally in order.
> Lots of cardio and getting bigger and/or stronger (what I assume you > mean by "progressing") don't work well together for most people most of > the time. Before changing your diet, try cutting back on the cardio. > > Just my opinion. Thanks, much appreciated; that seems to be the consensus all right, though I remember many an Army Ranger who's big and cut and yet who, like all Rangers, have to run run run five days a week, often twice daily. I just like an all-around level of health, which includes being able to run (and I don't mean simply putting one foot in front of the other for like ten minutes). I'm still resistant to the apparent notion that hypertrophy and strength is in some opposition to rigorous and fairly frequent aerobic activity.
So, anyway, any idea why they sell BCAA and glutamine, etc., separately if these things are already in whey protein powders??
> -S-http://www.kbnj.com > [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > > glutamine and BCAAs. So why are those two latter ingredients also > > sold separately??? Steve Freides - 03 May 2007 18:06 GMT >> Please define what "progressing" would be for you. > > Well, I mean, not stuck at some particular weight -- like 275-lbs. on > the bench press. I had done 315 at one time, for like two reps > unassisted, and another one or two with some assist, and now 275 is my > max. Still a respectable number and in the ballpark of your all-time max.
> I know numbers aren't everything, but they're an indicator, it seems. > So I'm thinking it's probably old age setting in, loss of testosterone [quoted text clipped - 16 lines] > apparent notion that hypertrophy and strength is in some opposition to > rigorous and fairly frequent aerobic activity. We're all the same in some ways and different in others - you have to find what works well for you.
I'm 52, and I'm _much_ happier doing strength/endurance training than I am with traditional cardio. If you're skinny like me, you can actually put on muscle while improving your cardiovascular health at the same time. I'm in the middle of a several month stretch of high volume, heavy kettlebell snatch training, and my weight has gone up a pound or two while my bodyfat has gone down, and my endurance has simply gone through the roof, .e.g, I can get in the pool and swim a length of front crawl without a breath, something that used to be difficult if not impossible for me. Yesterday I did 120 swing-style kettlebell snatches (60 per arm) in the form of short sets of 3-5 reps each (3-5 reps w/ one arm, switch arms, 3-5 reps the other arm, then put the bell down) followed by short rests, totalling 16 minutes worth in a format that works out to be about 25 second of lifting followed by 35 seconds of rest, give or take. The kettlebell weighs 32 kg (70 lbs.) and I weigh about 70 kg (154 lbs.)
So, there's aerobic activity and there's aerobic activity, and the traditional kind works less well, and weights work better, the older you get - that's my take on it, and I think this is often overlooked. As we get older, we lose muscle and you have to fight that. You can rest assured that I can, on no running training, still go out and complete the local 5k footrace at, if not my old racing times, then certainly at my old training pace.
> So, anyway, any idea why they sell BCAA and glutamine, etc., > separately if these things are already in whey protein powders?? I'm sure someone can give a scientific answer, but the short, real-world answer is that they sell whatever people are willing to buy.
Just my opinion.
-S- http://www.kbnj.com
Prisoner at War - 03 May 2007 19:22 GMT > Still a respectable number and in the ballpark of your all-time max. Thanks, but there's nothing like seeing a minimum of three plates on each end of the bar. Any less and it looks like "cheating" or slacking off! And it's not just this, but chin-ups, curls, everything else...I'm just not lifting as much for as many reps and sets as I used to be, and it's shocking because there are much older lifters who are still very capable. I seem to have burned brightly but quickly...???
You see, I also wonder about all the "old guys" I see in the gym...walking on treadmills, for example: why not go for a walk outside?? Never understood that. Whereas pumping iron, sure, that makes sense -- except now that I seem to be seeing diminishing returns, so I'm wondering if I shouldn't just do push-ups and chin-ups at home, simply.
> We're all the same in some ways and different in others - you have to > find what works well for you. [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > rest, give or take. The kettlebell weighs 32 kg (70 lbs.) and I weigh > about 70 kg (154 lbs.) Yeah, I noticed that you're real big on kettlebells! They look all right; wish my gym had 'em, for variety's sake, though I can't see that big of a difference between their employ and that of plain ol' dumb- and barbells. I'm not particularly familiar with kettlebell routines, but swinging 70-lbs. around as much as you do at your age sounds very healthy! =) I hope to be horseback riding or something like that when I get that point, probably only going to the gym occasionally for a bit of variety.
> So, there's aerobic activity and there's aerobic activity, and the > traditional kind works less well, and weights work better, the older you [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > the local 5k footrace at, if not my old racing times, then certainly at > my old training pace. Well, how would you feel the day after? And yeah, at a certain pace, I could jog all day, too...but there's nothing like that sense of near- effortless effort which comes from being in your prime...I dunno, I guess I'm just mourning my perceived loss of youthful vigor here...I don't think of myself as "old" but God damn it I sure ain't "happening" like I used to be...!
> I'm sure someone can give a scientific answer, but the short, real-world > answer is that they sell whatever people are willing to buy. LOL -- good point, of course.
I wonder if anyone's done a real documentary on bodybuilding, where they follow a muscleman around, drugs and injections and all. That would really be interesting...too bad ol' Craig Titus is in prison now! Seems like he would have been the ideal star of such a flick, given his apparent anti-Weider Bros. stance.
> Just my opinion. > > -S-http://www.kbnj.com Steve Freides - 03 May 2007 21:31 GMT >> Still a respectable number and in the ballpark of your all-time max. > [quoted text clipped - 40 lines] > like that when I get that point, probably only going to the gym > occasionally for a bit of variety. The DragonDoor forum is where many of the kettlebell folks, me included, hang out. If you want more of an explanation of why we prefer what we do to the alternatives, that's the place to ask. I bought my kettlebells one at a time - a 35 lb. and a 53 lb. will keep most folks happy for quite some time, and the DragonDoor materials are second to none when it comes to basic health and fitness. I'm one of their "kettlebell success stories" - you can read about it on their site, and there's a link from mine as well.
I do 95% of my working out at home - much simpler that way.
>> So, there's aerobic activity and there's aerobic activity, and the >> traditional kind works less well, and weights work better, the older you [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > don't think of myself as "old" but God damn it I sure ain't > "happening" like I used to be...! I do the local 5k every year - for the last decade or so, it's been keeping one or the other of my kids company. Haven't had to push the pace just yet. My youngest is 10 and it's still pretty easy for me to keep up with him.
I feel fine the day after, a bit sore as you'd expect from 20+ minutes of an unfamiliar activity. I went for a brief walk/run with my wife today to try to get a little more ready, about 2 miles, ran about half of it.
Anyway, best of luck to you. Anything else I can tell you, just holler. We all get older - you do the best you can, and I'm pretty happy with how it's going for me.
-S- http://www.kbnj.com
>> I'm sure someone can give a scientific answer, but the short, real-world >> answer is that they sell whatever people are willing to buy. [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] >> >> -S-http://www.kbnj.com Mu - 04 May 2007 21:31 GMT > You see, I also wonder about all the "old guys" I see in the > gym...walking on treadmills, for example: why not go for a walk > outside?? Never understood that. It doesn't get cold, overly hot, rain or snow in the gym. There is no better alternative to cardio than the consistency of use capability of a treadmill.
 Signature http://www.steppenwolf.com/lyr/mnnster.html
Prisoner at War - 11 May 2007 21:54 GMT > It doesn't get cold, overly hot, rain or snow in the gym. There is no > better alternative to cardio than the consistency of use capability of a > treadmill. How can you say that? Nothing like the real deal -- jogging totally under your own propulsion!
I can't believe the elements can make the monotony of the hamster wheel seem so attractive by comparison. I can do treadmills and tracks, but nothing like a real run from A to B...on through Z!
I really miss the Army sometimes...nothing like a platoon running through the post!
> --http://www.steppenwolf.com/lyr/mnnster.html Eh?
MattLB - 04 May 2007 13:39 GMT > So, anyway, any idea why they sell BCAA and glutamine, etc., > separately if these things are already in whey protein powders?? BCAA are unusual in that after they're absorbed from the gut into the blood they are taken up by the muscles not the liver. If you eat BCAA on their own then you're directly feeding the muscles. Glutamine is the most abundant amino acid in muscle tissue, so again, eating glutamine is giving muscles what they're made of.
Eating proteins provides these amino acids, but only as a component of the total. For hardcore bodybuilders where their stomach capacity is the limiting factor, eating muscle-centric amino acids as supplements can be seen as a more efficient way to sustain anabolic growth.
Creatine is a non-protein amino acid, that, once again, is enriched in muscle and acts as a rapid energy source for exercising muscles. Meat contains it, but plants or dairy don't, so a supplement is just easier.
MattLB
Will Brink - 04 May 2007 19:07 GMT > I know numbers aren't everything, but they're an indicator, it seems. > So I'm thinking it's probably old age setting in, loss of testosterone > levels, whatever, and I'm now wondering if some supplementation is > finally in order. If your diet, training, and hormones are in order, sure, no reason not to. If the former are not in order, than you know what you need to work on. See:
http://www.brinkzone.com/articledetails.php?acatid=3&aid=95
> I'm still resistant to the > apparent notion that hypertrophy and strength is in some opposition to > rigorous and fairly frequent aerobic activity. Yet your own experience seems to confirm it: strength has gone down and progress has not been made. Do the math.
 Signature Will @ www.BrinkZone.com
"It twas ever thus! " - Mr Natural
Bob - 04 May 2007 05:09 GMT >Researching the matter, there appears to be a million-and-one >ingredients necessary to optimal performance and growth, LOL. But a >few seem to consistently stand out. Like, first of all, protein. >Then creatine and glutamine and BCAAs...but aren't all these "-ines" >proteins?? no
Proteins are made of a standard set of 20 amino acid subunits.
Creatine is a modified amino acid, not found in any substantial amount in proteins.
Glutamine is in proteins, at some level. If indeed your were short of glutamine and needed more than what is found in your food, taking extra glutamine might make sense. I don't know why you would have such a deficiency.
What is BCAA?
bob
joanne - 04 May 2007 16:16 GMT > What is BCAA? Branched Chain Amino Acids : http://tinyurl.com/2ud7x8
joanne
Will Brink - 04 May 2007 19:02 GMT > So why are those two latter ingredients also > sold separately??? 'Cause they can. Next.
 Signature Will @ www.BrinkZone.com
"It twas ever thus! " - Mr Natural
Mu - 04 May 2007 21:33 GMT >> So why are those two latter ingredients also >> sold separately??? > > 'Cause they can. Next. And now for a better answer. Because they can be moderated to intake when separated.
 Signature http://www.steppenwolf.com/lyr/mnnster.html
Prisoner at War - 06 May 2007 14:37 GMT Hey Everyone,
Thanks for all the feedback. I'll try some supplementation -- whey protein and creatine to start -- and see how things work out. I certainly hope they do: these things can be expensive! I'm still skeptical, but at this point, I guess I don't have anything to lose. I'll also cut back on training, especially cardio, to see if that helps. Everything seems to be age-related...I'm still capable of putting in the time and effort, thank Goodness, but I'm just not getting the same returns, and that's extremely puzzling. So maybe at 35 I'm finally aging! It's really hard to believe...part of what made working out so fun, and why I could do it for hours on end, was the sheer sense of feeling my own growing power. Now that it seems like the opposite, I'm afraid I'm just going to quit in disgust! Who wants to be reminded of diminished capabilities with each and every lift, each and every mile??? I'll go troll some golfing or fishing newsgroup instead! ^_^
JMW - 06 May 2007 17:02 GMT > So maybe at > 35 I'm finally aging! It's really hard to believe...part of what made [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > each and every mile??? I'll go troll some golfing or fishing > newsgroup instead! ^_^ Maybe you should try seppuku.
Prisoner at War - 11 May 2007 21:50 GMT Maybe you should try lifting some real weights! Was that you in the video on your website? Some fat bald guy with a tub and a handlebar mustache trying to bench 185-lbs.???
Seriously, people like you make me fear old age!
> Maybe you should try seppuku. JMW - 11 May 2007 23:43 GMT >Maybe you should try lifting some real weights! Was that you in the >video on your website? Some fat bald guy with a tub and a handlebar >mustache trying to bench 185-lbs.??? Oh, you've never seen 100-pound plates before? I guess that's because you've never competed ... just Usenet lifts, right?
Does it bother you that I weigh less and lift more than you do, and I'm still about 20 years older?
Yes ...
>> Maybe you should try seppuku. Prisoner at War - 12 May 2007 00:36 GMT > Oh, you've never seen 100-pound plates before? I guess that's because > you've never competed ... just Usenet lifts, right? LOL!!! Yeah, sure, and how much did the bar weigh when inflated? =D
> Does it bother you that I weigh less and lift more than you do, and > I'm still about 20 years older? You mean those usenet lifts you were just talking about?? ^_^
> Yes ... sh.t, JMW, you sound like a comicbook muscleman, right down to the bald head and handlebar mustache -- I'm surprised you weren't wearing leopard-skin!
GraceJG@gmail.com - 14 May 2007 06:10 GMT > I'm thinking about trying out supplementation because I don't seem to > be progressing. The main culprit seems to be (so-called? I'm still [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > glutamine and BCAAs. So why are those two latter ingredients also > sold separately??? Hi, I am not a "know it all" but I would like to take a shot at answering your question, if I may.
but aren't all these "-ines"
> proteins?? It seems pure whey protein powders already contain > glutamine and BCAAs. So why are those two latter ingredients also > sold separately??? because every "body" has different needs. try using protein and extra BCAA for about 6 weeks, than try protein and extra glutamine for 6 weeks and see which prduced the best results for you, if you are not happy with either try a combo of all for 6 weeks. I would say find a nutritionalist, better yet, a dr. natural medicine have him/her test your nutritional levels (which vitamins enzymes minerals) your body is lacking and which you may have too much of, then let her/him decide what will enhance your body performance. I hope I am making sense, I am just trying to help. Personally I am a fan of juicing, and I do a lot of research. I know my body needs extra B3 (niacin which I take just before going to sleep) B5 (pantothenic acid) B6 and B12 aside from taking a B-Complex. B Vitamins are responsible for metabolism of proteins fat and calories, it would really be beneficial if you knew what vitamins minerals and enzymes do, this way you can really boost your results. My favorite book is Prescription for Natural Healing. I read it and go back to it all the time. It gives you side effects, interactions, suggested dosage and defeciency symptoms. I got it on ebay, it's the cheapest. Take care and good luck. Kat
|
|
|