Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion GroupsGeneral TopicsLow CarbWeightWatchers
WeightAdviser.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Weight Loss Forum / General Topics / May 2010

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Diet colas ?

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
PB - 23 Apr 2010 05:18 GMT
I have so few pleasures left, can't keep diet coke/pepsi as one ?

Bad for weight gain ? No one seems sure. zero calories, but something
about aspartame and sugar substitutes, I don't know.

Gonna just eat raw and drink water, except can't afford healthy food
vegan diet.

That's why poor people are fat. Junk and processed foods are cheaper.
Doug Freyburger - 23 Apr 2010 16:59 GMT
> I have so few pleasures left, can't keep diet coke/pepsi as one ?

Are diet sodas harmful?  Probably.  Are regular sugar sodas harmful?
Definitely.  Chances are the diet sodas are no worse and may be a little
less bad than regular sugar sodas.

I have no reaction to aspartame but I do know a small number of people
who do.  It blocks any attempt for my wife to lose and she's gone
through several cycles to demonstrate that happening.  I prefer Diet
Rite or Diet RC Cola over either Diet Coke or Diet Pepsi because of
this.  Diet Rite was the first on the market to switch to Splenda as its
sweetener.

Of course eventually problems will emerge about Splenda use just they do
with all artificial sweeteners, but there's no way they will end up as
common as aspartame problems.  And I know my wife is one of the few who
have some sort of reaction to aspartame and neither of us have short
term issues with Splenda.

> Bad for weight gain ? No one seems sure. zero calories, but something
> about aspartame and sugar substitutes, I don't know.

I've known several people who drank diet sodas nearly to the exclusion
of regular water.  They are fat.  Diet sodas have no calories so they
may not contribute to weight gain but they certainly do nothing to help
loss.  But is loss really about the liquids as long as you drink actual
water for your daily quota and have sodas in addition?  I don't think so
unless you're experimented with stalls and seen the stalls break as soon
as you stopped aspartame.

> Gonna just eat raw and drink water, except can't afford healthy food
> vegan diet.

The idea that vegan food is healthy is false.  There are valid reasons
for going vegan and if one of those reasons applies to you then do it.
But please don't use a false reason and then end up wondering why yet
another attempt at dieting failed.

> That's why poor people are fat. Junk and processed foods are cheaper.

Cheaper in terms of time and convenience.  If you compare the dollar
cost of going to fast food places for a month with buying on sale meat
and low price veggies for a month the dollar cost isn't going to be
higher for the healthy food.  And if you use beans in a crockpot for a
fraction of your food that makes it a lot cheaper in dollars.  The cost
of the healthy foods is the effort not the dollars, and in the learning
to buy based on price and the initial shopping trips that you end up
buying the worng foods before you relearn.  The first month may cost
more dollars but not later months.  It's the effort that's higher.

And once you consider the price in effort, making the inherently
problematic vegan approach healthy takes significantly more effort.
Humans are omnivores in objective fact and so it is very easy to cover
our metabolic needs by mixing meat and veggies and fruit and nuts
without much advance planning.  Just have some of each and pay a little
attention to variety and it works.  With vegan it takes planning to
acheive a healthy result.  More price in the coinage of thought and
effort.

I think the more critical aspect is the fact that fast foods are
designed to trigger cravings for more of them.  They tap instinctive
cravings for rich/fatty, sweet/starchy and salty, and they do it with
little other nutrition so they don't really let the hunger go completely
away.
PB - 23 Apr 2010 22:20 GMT
> > I have so few pleasures left, can't keep diet coke/pepsi as one ?
>
[quoted text clipped - 60 lines]
> little other nutrition so they don't really let the hunger go completely
> away.

So....doesn't cause weight gain but prevents weight loss ?

I'm lost. Difference between aspartame and other artificial
sweeteners ?
Doug Freyburger - 24 Apr 2010 01:41 GMT
> So....doesn't cause weight gain but prevents weight loss ?

That's what aspartame does to my wife.  Not even a worst case for ill
effects from it.  Most folks get no ill effects.

But do think about anyone you know who drinks diet sodas in the place of
other liquids.  Are any of them thin or are all of them fat?

> I'm lost. Difference between aspartame and other artificial
> sweeteners ?

All of them either have known problems or will some day.  Aspartame is
the one with the most problems.
Del Cecchi - 05 May 2010 04:13 GMT
>> So....doesn't cause weight gain but prevents weight loss ?
>
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> All of them either have known problems or will some day.  Aspartame is
> the one with the most problems.

Are they fat because they drink diet soda?  Or do they drink diet soda
because they are fat?
username854 - 19 May 2010 17:04 GMT
I dont drink that,better drink mineral water

--
username854
robrobin10 - 24 Apr 2010 03:24 GMT
Aspartame is dangerous for other reasons, it isn't just a drug whic
causes problems with people
who want to lose excess weight. Of course its important that you don'
deny yourself all pleasures
in life, but honestly I would advise you drop the diet soda

--
robrobin10
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2012 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.