Weight Loss Forum / General Topics / July 2004
Should I invite an obese friend here?
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Dally - 07 Jul 2004 20:07 GMT A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was kicked out of the pre-op room for having absurdly high blood pressure. She has since decided to abandon the surgery idea.
She's not a close friend, but someone in my small church community, our husbands are pretty good friends, I hang out with her at church events, invite them to parties at our house (and they come), and send christmas cards to them; that sort of friend.
I knew about the pre-op problem, but her Mom (a client of mine) just told me she has joined weight watchers and is giving up on the idea of surgery.
What I want to know, and the reason I'm posting this here is, do you think I should approach her with advice? This group is so strong, so powerful, so knowledgeable, so supportive... should I get her in here? I'm not one to proselytize. When she said she was having surgery I just said "good luck" rather than tried to talk her out of it (and I've tried hard to talk people out of it online before.)
She knows I've lost 65 pounds over the past two years, but a.) 65 pounds in two years seems so slow it's not worth doing from her perspective and b.) I was never morbidly obese so what would I know? She's never asked me how I did it. I saw her eating cookies right before the surgery and she laughed abashedly and said she had to get them while she could. (I neither commented nor judged, except to think that she wasn't quite ready to do this yet.)
Dally
Ignoramus14410 - 07 Jul 2004 20:22 GMT With the same level of effort as yours, she would be losing, initially, quite a lot faster than you did.
Is she the type of person who freaks out and gets mad at messengers when they bring up reality to her, even when the message is delivered in a relatively gentle fashion? If so, I would suggest not to bring her here.
Try to imagine this conversation. She says, "I want to become a normal healthy person soon". You say "well, since you have so much to lose, over 300 lbs, there is no way this could be done quickly". What would her reaction be? Would she become upset, start crying, start binging on cookies to calm down etc? Think about it.
Otherwise, it is hard to see a person who is willing to listen with an open mind, whose efforts would be hurt by this newsgroup.
And then there is an issue, suppose she comes in here and someone says something that she does not like. Would that jeopardize your relationship?
Also, you post a bunch of private, personal stuff here knowing that no one else who reads this ng knows the rest of your family. Would you be as comfortable posting?
These are some things to think about.
There is this one guy Matty, who used to post here until very recently, and who started losing weight at 520 lbs starting weight. This ng seems to be an accountability outlet to him.
i http://igor.chudov.com/weightloss/ (updated) 223/172/180
Dally - 07 Jul 2004 20:25 GMT > With the same level of effort as yours, she would be losing, > initially, quite a lot faster than you did. [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > Otherwise, it is hard to see a person who is willing to listen with an > open mind, whose efforts would be hurt by this newsgroup. Okay, Igor, no offense meant (and I'm sure none will be taken) but you're the only person here who is LESS diplomatic and sensitive than I am. Neither you nor I are any good at telling when we're being offensive. So how am I supposed to guess how she'll react?
Dally
Ignoramus14410 - 07 Jul 2004 20:32 GMT >> With the same level of effort as yours, she would be losing, >> initially, quite a lot faster than you did. [quoted text clipped - 17 lines] > am. Neither you nor I are any good at telling when we're being > offensive. So how am I supposed to guess how she'll react? No offense taken Dally.
I have no idea! With some people, it is next to impossible not to offend them when gently trying to bring up reality. Which is not to say that your witty comment above has no merit, it does have merit. Anyhow, I thought that perhaps you know that friend and observed her personal interactions. Maybe she complained about some people who "mistreated" her, whereas you think that she was not mistreated, that sort of thing.
i
Kasey - 08 Jul 2004 04:22 GMT >>What I want to know, and the reason I'm posting this here is, do you think I should approach her with advice?<<
Absolutely not.
This woman knows how much she weighs, she knows the health issues, she knows the difficulty of life as a supermorbidly obese person.
When she is ready to try something other than surgery, she will. Nothing you do or say will get her to that place any sooner.
If (and this is a big IF) this woman asks you how you lost weight, by all means tell her what you found helpful, including this newsgroup.
But unless she asks you directly, MYOB.
As always, YMMV.
Kasey 365/257/???
Dally - 13 Jul 2004 04:47 GMT >>>What I want to know, and the reason I'm posting this here is, do you > [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > When she is ready to try something other than surgery, she will. > Nothing you do or say will get her to that place any sooner. Kasey, I absolutely agree with this. I had no thought or intention of inviting her here because I had some idea that she should lose weight, I only considered it after hearing that SHE had decided to lose weight.
When I was fat I was fat because I didn't choose not to be. I was putting my energies into other things, I valued recreational eating, I valued relaxation time over sweaty exercise, and I am not vain and didn't value my looks. I remember this distinctly and very rarely have an opinion on whether anyone else should make the same choices I've made. (The exception to this rule are my parents. I wish they'd make healthier choices so I'd have them around longer.)
> If (and this is a big IF) this woman asks you how you lost weight, by > all means tell her what you found helpful, including this newsgroup. > > But unless she asks you directly, MYOB. That was my first instinct. But it felt unkind. She was looking for just this sort of info, I had it, but I wanted to keep it secret so I could have my own private club? That just seems wrong. Besides, she'll fit right in here. She's got a good sense of humor, she's articulate, she's self-aware... (Have you forgiven me yet, Carolyn?) :-)
> As always, YMMV. > > Kasey > 365/257/??? Kasey, you're one of the reasons I told her there were peoople here who could help her. You've dropped over 100 pounds! That's just fantastic. Can you remind me, how are you doing it?
Dally
Mun_ Between The Stones - 13 Jul 2004 16:44 GMT >When I was fat I was fat because I didn't choose not to be. I was >putting my energies into other things, I valued recreational eating, I >valued relaxation time over sweaty exercise, and I am not vain and >didn't value my looks. I remember this distinctly and very rarely have >an opinion on whether anyone else should make the same choices I've >made. Someone ought to carve this paragraph in granite and hang it on the "door" to this newsgroup as a constant reminder that first and foremost to a healthier life is accepting personal responsibility for one's actions (or lack thereof). http://antwrp.gsfc.nasa.gov/apod/ap960222.html Lift well, Eat less, Walk fast, Live long.
JMA - 07 Jul 2004 20:48 GMT > A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > > Dally If you don't have a problem letting her into "your world" so to speak, then you can't really do harm by recommending it. You could just let her know that this was one of the tools that has helped you to succeed thus far.
I have a few friends that I've sent this way. One was instantly turned off by the trolling and the way certain people just knew everything about me (not) by a making ASSumptions on info in posts. It was also at the time when someone had decided to make me the target of a bunch of their snark so I could see that being a turnoff. She also is not familiar with usenet in general and that there are all kinds out there. Another still lurks and sends me occasional pithy emails :)
I refer friends who want dieting and exercise advice regardless of how much they need to lose. Keep in mind I live in the middle of nowhere with very few non-Internet resources.
Jenn
Dally - 08 Jul 2004 00:53 GMT >>What I want to know, and the reason I'm posting this here is, do you >>think I should approach her with advice? This group is so strong, so [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] >>neither commented nor judged, except to think that she wasn't quite >>ready to do this yet.)
> If you don't have a problem letting her into "your world" so to speak, then > you can't really do harm by recommending it. You could just let her know > that this was one of the tools that has helped you to succeed thus far. I like her and would be happy to have her in "my world" (LOL, as if she weren't already, did I mention we both belong to the same small church and our husbands are buddies?)
The only problem is this thread. Oh my God, I described her so cruelly if she comes in here and sees this. I mean, my estimate of 500 pounds is probably wildly off - I could never judge people's weight. When I weighed 244 I felt like I was pudgy. (Pictoral evidence suggests otherwise, BTW.) What if she only weighs 325 and sees that? I honestly can't gauge weight. (CB, if you're reading this, consider it an apology ... as well as an advance taste of just how cruel usenet can be. But please believe me when I say there's value along with the harshness.)
> I refer friends who want dieting and exercise advice regardless of how much > they need to lose. Keep in mind I live in the middle of nowhere with very > few non-Internet resources. I think that the resources offered by the knowledge in this group are so far superior to what people can find on their own that it's shocking.
Dally
Ignoramus14410 - 08 Jul 2004 01:17 GMT > I think that the resources offered by the knowledge in this group are so > far superior to what people can find on their own that it's shocking. I know for sure I would not be able to get where I am without this newsgroup, support, accountability, and collective knowledge.
i 223/172/180 http://igor.chudov.com/weightloss/
janice - 08 Jul 2004 07:08 GMT >The only problem is this thread. Oh my God, I described her so cruelly >if she comes in here and sees this. I mean, my estimate of 500 pounds [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] >... as well as an advance taste of just how cruel usenet can be. But >please believe me when I say there's value along with the harshness.) Dally, if you tell her about this group at all it's a fair bet she'll take a peek even if she doesn't admit it, so if I were you I'd tell her about the thread and what you've said about her. Who knows, being taken for 500 lbs when you weigh less could in itself be a wake-up call. Anyway, it's possible she herself doesn't know how much she weighs.
janice
jmk - 08 Jul 2004 13:31 GMT > When I > weighed 244 I felt like I was pudgy. (Pictoral evidence suggests > otherwise, BTW.) What if she only weighs 325 and sees that? I honestly > can't gauge weight. I know what you mean! I always used the excuse that I was "big boned" and therefore OK. Well, as it turns out I am SMALL boned. <sigh> I shared this info with DH and he said, you thought that you were big boned?! :-( So yes, I can totally understand that you might not be able to judge someone else's weight. I couldn't even judge my own!
P.S. Maybe wait a few weeks and then invite her ;-)
 Signature jmk in NC
byakee - 08 Jul 2004 20:09 GMT One dark day on Usenet, Dally <dally@myself.com> said:
<snip>
> The only problem is this thread. Oh my God, I described her so cruelly Don't beat yourself up -- you're just trying to help someone with a problem that you've faced and (from what I can tell) defeated. "Cruel" would be calling her names or making fun of her; you were just being honest in how you see things.
> if she comes in here and sees this. I mean, my estimate of 500 pounds > is probably wildly off - I could never judge people's weight. When I > weighed 244 I felt like I was pudgy. (Pictoral evidence suggests > otherwise, BTW.) What if she only weighs 325 and sees that? I honestly > can't gauge weight. Oh Lord, neither can I! I hate it when people ask me how much I think they weigh -- I have no idea. I can't estimate sizes either.
> (CB, if you're reading this, consider it an apology > .... as well as an advance taste of just how cruel usenet can be. But > please believe me when I say there's value along with the harshness.) I hope that if she does read here, she will understand that your heart is in the right place -- if you didn't care about here, you wouldn't have mentioned her at all.
> > I refer friends who want dieting and exercise advice regardless of how much > > they need to lose. Keep in mind I live in the middle of nowhere with very > > few non-Internet resources. > > I think that the resources offered by the knowledge in this group are so > far superior to what people can find on their own that it's shocking. You've got that right! Having you guys has made the weight loss challenge sooooo much easier. I thank you all... :-)
 Signature J.J. in WA * 275/230/225 (mini) (COLD to HOT for e-mail)
Rich - 11 Jul 2004 20:56 GMT > The only problem is this thread. Oh my God, I described her so > cruelly if she comes in here and sees this. Just make sure you go onto her computer with her, using her news reader program, and mark the current threads as "Read." Then she'll have to do something extraordinary to re-read them and if it's as busy as most news servers, the messages will have rolled off after a while.
I seriously doubt that she will get much value from your assistance until she asks for it, however. The fact that she was pounding down cookies while waiting for her bariatric surgery says to me that she's still not accepting of the effort required to lose the weight.
--- Never trust a computer that you can lift. (from the Mainframe Forum)
Dally - 13 Jul 2004 04:52 GMT >>The only problem is this thread. Oh my God, I described her so >>cruelly if she comes in here and sees this. [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > something extraordinary to re-read them and if it's as busy as most news > servers, the messages will have rolled off after a while. LOL, this sounds like a plot to an "I Love Lucy" show updated for the 21st century!
> I seriously doubt that she will get much value from your assistance until > she asks for it, however. The fact that she was pounding down cookies > while waiting for her bariatric surgery says to me that she's still not > accepting of the effort required to lose the weight. I didn't say "pounding down"! And I've heard of other people doing that, having goodies while they can before they lose the ability to eat that stuff altogether. I really didn't judge, except to think that she's wasn't ready to hear about this group. But then I heard that she WAS ready, and that's when I started this thread.
By the way, I sometimes have goodies at fellowship hour, too. The trick is to not have them every day, all day long. :-)
Dally
ELTHIA Pea - 11 Jul 2004 22:19 GMT WHAT A OPEN GROUP......MY WEIGHT IS 270 LB. AND THAT IS 2 MUCH....<
Dally - 13 Jul 2004 04:53 GMT > WHAT A OPEN GROUP......MY WEIGHT IS 270 LB. AND THAT IS 2 MUCH....<> Are you ready to change that? You can, you know. All the hoo-hah about diets not working doesn't seem to apply here. We keep at it until they DO work.
A great starting resource is http://www.stumptuous.com/weights.html and look for the section on Eating 101.
Dally 244/175.5/169
Jane Lumley - 09 Jul 2004 17:58 GMT >> She knows I've lost 65 pounds over the past two years, but a.) 65 pounds >> in two years seems so slow it's not worth doing from her perspective and [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] >> neither commented nor judged, except to think that she wasn't quite >> ready to do this yet.) I would tell her again how you've lost weight, going into plenty of detail. A friend did this for me a while back and even though I'd always said I was happy, it actually motivated me to start serious diet and exercise. I lost 40 pounds in four months, and have kept most of it off.
 Signature Jane Lumley
Carolyn Bellany - 12 Jul 2004 20:23 GMT I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have lost 9.6 pounds. I now weigh 340 pounds, which is a lot, but I am glad I am not starting at 500 pounds. I had prepared for the bariatric surgery for over a year, and was extremely disappointed when the doctor first said Ihe couldn't do it. Now I am really glad that I didn't have it. . I have a normal blood pressure; a week ago it was 120/70. But on the table it soared to 215/157. I guess unconsciously I did not want the surgery. Aside from the WW plan, I am going into an adjustable current pool three times a week to do exercises and swimming. I have had two total knee replacements and one of them is broken so I am limited in walking and some of the exercises I can do. However, I have also started, rather gingerly, so weight/resistance work. I am glad that my friend cared enough to tell me about the group and look forward to your support and helpful information. Still trying and will get there yet!
> >> She knows I've lost 65 pounds over the past two years, but a.) 65 pounds > >> in two years seems so slow it's not worth doing from her perspective and [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > and exercise. I lost 40 pounds in four months, and have kept most of it > off. Ignoramus32482 - 12 Jul 2004 20:33 GMT Good luck Carolyn. You can lose weight without walking and such. There are people in this newsgroup who started off with even higher weight, and lost weight, so what you are setting out to do is not impossible, merely difficult. Don't expect quick miracles and do expect some bumps along the way. Try to find things that work for you personally.
i
Beverly - 12 Jul 2004 20:58 GMT Welcome to ASD, Carolyn.
I'm a WW member, too. I lost my orignial weight in '84 and have been able to stay close to goal except for the year I quit smoking. It's a sensible plan and I've always been able to lose weight if I follow the plan.
I'm glad you decided to join us. I'm sure the water exercise and weight training will be fine. The important thing is to do what you can.
Hope to see you posting often.
Beverly
> I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating > table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > > and exercise. I lost 40 pounds in four months, and have kept most of it > > off. byakee - 12 Jul 2004 21:21 GMT One dark day on Usenet, jbellany@localnet.com (Carolyn Bellany) said:
> I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating > table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have > lost 9.6 pounds. Welcome Carolyn! And congrats on losing nearly 10 pounds already, that's fantastic!
> I now weigh 340 pounds, which is a lot, but I am glad I am not > starting at 500 pounds. Yeah, that's 160 pounds you *don't* have to lose. <smile>
> I had prepared for the > bariatric surgery for over a year, and was extremely disappointed when > the doctor first said Ihe couldn't do it. Now I am really glad that I > didn't have it. . I have a normal blood pressure; a week ago it was > 120/70. But on the table it soared to 215/157. I guess unconsciously > I did not want the surgery. Like you, I nearly had the surgery too, but my insurance company pulled the plug at the last minute because I hadn't yet tried a doctor-assisted diet. Now I'm doing that -- cutting back on calories and exercising, and have lost 42 pounds so far. I'm really glad I didn't have the surgery, and bet you will be too.
> Aside from the WW plan, I am going into > an adjustable current pool three times a week to do exercises and [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > group and look forward to your support and helpful information. > Still trying and will get there yet! The pool is a great idea -- I wish we had something like that in my area. Best wishes, and again, welcome!
 Signature J.J. in WA * 275/233/225 (mini) (COLD to HOT for e-mail)
janice - 12 Jul 2004 21:59 GMT >I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating >table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] >group and look forward to your support and helpful information. >Still trying and will get there yet! Welcome Carolyn and I'm so glad you decided to come here and join us.
It sounds like you've already taken some important steps which show that you want to make changes in your life. There are others here who have come down a long way from over 300 lbs, and I'm sure you'll find the support and the valuable information you can get here of help in your journey.
janice
Chris Braun - 12 Jul 2004 23:35 GMT >I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating >table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] >group and look forward to your support and helpful information. >Still trying and will get there yet! Welcome to ASD, Carolyn! This is a great group and you'll find a lot of help here. You'll see lots of different approaches that have worked for different people, but you can learn something from almost everyone.
I'm glad you didn't have the surgery. I know you can do this without it. I have lost 118 lbs. in the past two years through diet and exercise -- and have had fun doing it. (I'm a 56 year old woman, by the way.) Just take it a day at a time, and remember that every pound lost is a victory.
And I'm also glad that you don't have to start at 500 :-).
Chris 262/144/ (145-150)
p.s. Have you figured out our signature lines yet? The first number is starting weight, the second is current weight, and the third is goal weight. I have a goal range of 145-150, which I'm actually a pound below at the moment.
Dally - 13 Jul 2004 04:29 GMT > And I'm also glad that you don't have to start at 500 :-). And I'm *particularly* glad that you don't seem mad at me for my gross mischaracterization! :-)
I'm so sorry, I never even considered what your weight might actually be, nor did I consider that anyone would care if I exagerated the situation. I've never ever looked at you and thought, "hmmm, she must weigh X!" I just don't think in terms of numbers. My original characterization was by way of saying which general category you fell into. We've got a number of very large people here, but we've also got a number of people who really want to trim down from 145 to 120.
In fact, one of the lessons I teach here is the value of ignoring WEIGHT and concentrating on losing FAT. I care a whole lot more about body fat percentages than anything else. I'm at 176 pounds today and getting pretty close to goal, yet most woman would consider 170 an awful goal weight. But I'm strong, have strong bones and I don't want to lose weight just to lose weight, I want to lose fat.
I don't know if you were offended by the term "obese", but we use it in a clinical sense here. There isn't any perjorative sense, because we're all here just dealing with the hand we're dealt from where we stand. It's one of the things that is really refreshing about this group. We help the people who want to be helped and leave the other ones alone.
And that's the next point I'll make: a few of us know each other in real life and I don't know exactly how they do it, but I'm not the Diet Police and I won't be judging your progess or shaking a naughty finger at you at fellowship hour or peering in your cart at the grocery store. (Okay, I might peer in the cart, it's a peeping tom problem of mine.) :-)
I'm not here to judge (and I hope you won't be judging ME, either) but here for community and education and support and affection. No one can make you choose to do this and we absolutely know it won't be easy, so no one will blame you if you decide the pitfalls outweigh the benefits. That's your personal choice to make. And my experience is that I have to choose not to be fat EVERY DAY. Over and over again.
This morning I had my neighbor and her two kids interacting with my three kids and we had car problems and... finally I threw up my hands in disgust and announced that my workout was NOT going to revolve around 7 people's schedules and I was just going to WALK to the Y and leave all the kids home alone. Which I then did. And no one died. :-) But the point is that I had to choose to work out today and it was just as difficult a choice as it ever gets. No one would have blamed me if I stayed home.
We're all on different diets, we all do different exercises, but the recurring theme is our methods all boil down to the same four steps:
1. Eat less 2. Exercise more 3. Repeat 4. Forever.
Each step has it's own issues and struggles and that's where this group comes in. I'm on steps three and four, but it took me 3 whole months to make exercise normal in my life and another three months after that to really start eating less. Six months just to learn how to do this. During the first three months I lost 5 pounds. During the second three months I lost 15 pounds. It all seems so pointless when you look at that pace. But over the two years since I decided to do this I've lost nearly 70 pounds. Step by step, and along the way I figured out how to live so that I maintain this loss.
So welcome to the journey, and once again, I apologize for what must have been a disturbing intro to this group!
My name, here, by the way, is an old nickname of my actual first name, Wendalyn.
I recommend you get a name that isn't as easy to link to you via google just for anonymity and an account to use a spamtrap. You'll also want to use a different newsfeed than google. The google newsfeed is so horribly slow - the rest of us see posts almost immediately after we post them and get responses in real time if someone else happens to be on.
Find another email account at www.mail.com (there are lots of other places, but that's where I got my free account) and after you've got a valid address you can sign up for free usenet newsfeed from http://news.individual.net/ and link it to the news part of whichever way you get your email (Outlook?) or download a free usenet news reader from somewhere and we'll have you all set up in a jiffy!
Phew! Was that information overload or what? Luckily, you can always google to recall what was in this thread. :-)
I'm so glad you came here!
Dally 244/175.5/169
SnugBear - 13 Jul 2004 03:15 GMT Carolyn wrote:
> I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating > table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > group and look forward to your support and helpful information. > Still trying and will get there yet! Hi Carolyn! You can get a lot of good ideas and even a few laughs here. I've been maintaining my near hundred pound loss for almost 17 months and participating in the group is a way I can keep focused. It's great to know there are others in the same boat.
Take some measurements and *before* pictures. When you're done, you'll be glad. Enjoy the journey to your new life <s>
 Signature Walking on . . . Laurie in Maine 207/110 60 inches of attitude! Start: 2/02 Maintained since 2/03
JMA - 13 Jul 2004 03:30 GMT > I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating > table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > group and look forward to your support and helpful information. > Still trying and will get there yet! Welcome to the group. You've already been given a little info to go on. My dad and his wife did very well with WW. I used to weigh over 300 lbs and lost half of that on a doctor supervised liquid diet. I learned a lot about nutrition and exercise from members of this group. I hope you find it helpful.
Jenn
beeswing - 13 Jul 2004 04:25 GMT jbellany@localnet.com wrote:
>I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating >table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] >group and look forward to your support and helpful information. >Still trying and will get there yet! I'm glad you decided to stop by. There are a lot people here that are or have been in similar shoes...I've found it very helpful to be able to get support and information along my weight loss journey and into maintenance. It sound like you are doing all the right things, from finding an eating program that works for you to trying out aquatic exercise. I'm sure you'll reach your goal! Some people find it easier to pick smaller goals along the way instead of dealing with the big picture up front, by the way. If that might help you, it's something to consider.
Welcome!
beeswing
Heywood Mogroot - 13 Jul 2004 07:23 GMT > I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating > table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > the doctor first said Ihe couldn't do it. Now I am really glad that I > didn't have it. . me too. my office mate nearly died from it, and I think getting an irreversible procedure is just short-sighted. All you need to do is lose 2lbs/week on average for the next 2 years and you'll be in great shape, and I don't think anyone needs surgery to lose at this gentle rate.
The people getting the surgery revel in their 20lbs+ per month loss rates, but that's just unhealthy, and unnecessary. Any 1 or 2lb loss in a week is a good week! That's all you need IMO, since by consistency and persistence any amount can be lost.
> group and look forward to your support and helpful information. > Still trying and will get there yet! We're in quite different circumstances, so my advice may or may not be applicable to you.
First, I think WW points penalize healthy fats like almonds too much. If you're happy with WW then ignore me here, but I tried to talk my sister who is on WW into eating 1oz of almonds (200kcal) and just treating it as 2pts not the 4...
I swear by spicy-flavored almonds as a nice mid-day snack that is very tasty, salty (goes great with my water), good protein (6g), a bit of fiber (3g), and enough unsaturated fat (15g) to really satiate for two hours or more.
This goes into my personal dieting theory that healthy unsaturated fats are GOOD to eat, since the body wants and needs fats. Better to eat 16g/day of fat in a rationed manner than a whole boxload on a weekly treat day IMO.
Make sure you drink a LOT of water. 1/2 gallon (2l) per day is the minimum.
Keep your goals on the long-term, and just focus on WHY you're dieting and WHERE you want to be.
Before I started this diet I had absolutely no faith that I could stick to it or that I could lose the weight that I did so easily. I'm a guy so I probably had an easier time than you will, but I think my experiences are common for asd'ers here.
Stick to a weekly loss rate goal (mine is 2lbs/week). This is a consistent 1000 kcal/day deficit, or approx. ~2000 kcal/day of food (you should be burning ~3000kcal/day total). PLAN your meals out to hit this 2000 kcal/day target every day. Don't undereat and don't overeat -- you're on a scientific diet. Since you're already doing WW that should be good enough to work for you, so again ignore this if WW is working for you.
Don't try to lose the weight at all at once -- starving yourself is only a short-term strategy, and you need to put your eating into a long-term mode.
If you eat less and exercise more you WILL lose the weight. If you eat healthy small snacks with plenty of protein and (healthy) fat you'll find that hunger won't be a big issue (at least that's what I've found).
Good luck, and stay with the program!
Heywood
232/192/182
beeswing - 13 Jul 2004 15:30 GMT >Keep your goals on the long-term, and just focus on WHY you're dieting >and WHERE you want to be. I feel for our new original poster! What you wrote exactly contradicts what I wrote. I wrote that I prefer to have reasonable, rather short-term weight goals.
How I find it works best *for me* is that I set reasonable weight goals and put my goalposts out a ways so that they are always achievable. For example, right now I want to weigh a set amount by the end of August . It's a fairly small drop in weight (I'm hoping for at least 5 to 7 pounds), but it's been a struggle for me, so I figure that gives me enough to time to do it without stressing myself unnaturally. Having a number to aim at motivates me, and having it be a *reasonable number* keeps me from getting too frustrated. And when I hit my goal well in time, it gives me a sense of satisfaction.
Earlier, when I had more weight to lose, I would reach that goal and then set another moderate, lower one. And move on to achieving that one.
So, everyone is different. The OP will be getting tons of ideas here, to sort through and see what works best for her.
beeswing
Carolyn Bellany - 19 Jul 2004 17:58 GMT iThanks, Heywood and everyone else who welcomed me. I agree about the al,omds, in fact my Dr. told me that they are one of he best snacks I could have. Right now I am allowed 33 points a day with WW, so can fight the count in rather easily. As my weight and point allowance lower, I will try to adjust my attitude so I can still allow for these healthy fates. Carolyn
> Good luck, and stay with the program! > > Heywood > > 232/192/182 A Ross - 13 Jul 2004 12:18 GMT In article <2908fc26.0407121123.37744767@posting.google.com>,
> I am the obese friend. Welcome, Carolyn! I hope you find a lot of good information and support.
Amy
J A Cooper - 15 Jul 2004 16:46 GMT >I am glad that my friend cared enough to tell me about the >group and look forward to your support and helpful information. >Still trying and will get there yet! I'm glad you're here too! Welcome to the group.
Teri - 15 Jul 2004 19:13 GMT > >I am glad that my friend cared enough to tell me about the > >group and look forward to your support and helpful information. > >Still trying and will get there yet! Piggy backing on a post - You seem to have snuck in there somewhere. Welcome, pull up a chair and a tall glass of water. :-) Teri
Cynthia Perry - 15 Jul 2004 19:13 GMT >I am the obese friend. Two weeks ago after my scare on the operating >table, I immediately returned to Weight Watchers. Since then, I have [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] >group and look forward to your support and helpful information. >Still trying and will get there yet! Hey welcome! And congrats on losing the 9.6 pounds!
Weight Watchers is a decent plan, my mother lost weight and kept it off with WW.
A pool is a great way to exercise, so is weight/resistance training.
Don't give up, keep trying and remember any progress IS progress!
Cynthia
byakee - 07 Jul 2004 20:50 GMT One dark day on Usenet, Dally <dally@myself.com> said:
> A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was > kicked out of the pre-op room for having absurdly high blood pressure. > She has since decided to abandon the surgery idea. <snip>
> What I want to know, and the reason I'm posting this here is, do you > think I should approach her with advice? This group is so strong, so > powerful, so knowledgeable, so supportive... should I get her in here? You should certainly suggest it -- can't hurt. She's made no secret of the fact that she wants to lose weight, so it's not as if you'd be insulting her (you know how some people just aren't ready to face the truth). Is she Usenet literate?
> I'm not one to proselytize. When she said she was having surgery I just > said "good luck" rather than tried to talk her out of it (and I've tried > hard to talk people out of it online before.) Heh, it's a lot easier to push someone OL than in RL.
> She knows I've lost 65 pounds over the past two years, but a.) 65 pounds > in two years seems so slow it's not worth doing from her perspective and > b.) I was never morbidly obese so what would I know? She's never asked > me how I did it. She probably had her hopes pinned on the surgery -- that it, alone, would solve her weight issues.
> I saw her eating cookies right before the surgery and > she laughed abashedly and said she had to get them while she could. (I > neither commented nor judged, except to think that she wasn't quite > ready to do this yet.) I was scheduled for surgery too, until my insurance company pulled the plug. Best thing that ever happened, IMHO. Anyway, up until then, I remember eating a lot because I was worried about not getting to after surgery. One lovely thing about calorie counting -- you can eat what you want, just beware of how much. Anyway, this might be the perfect place for her...
 Signature J.J. in WA * 275/230/225 (mini) (COLD to HOT for e-mail)
A Ross - 07 Jul 2004 21:12 GMT > A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound > range is my guess. Snip
I think it's great that you think enough of this person, and are comfortable enough with her, to want to give her a tool to use to help lose weight. I wish I could do the same for my mother.
It may help if you start a conversation with her about your online friends and the amount of support and advice they have given you during your journey. Maybe she'll be interested and ask more--maybe she won't. But that will put the ball in her court, and you won't sound preachy.
I know I lurked for a good long time before I ever made my first post here, so I was pretty familiar with personalities and WOEs. I would suggest she do something similar--if only to avoid the trolls and know-it-alls.
Anyway, go ahead and invite her in! There's a lot of WW and exWW WOEs here, maybe we can help her with points!
Amy
168/117/115 I'm in the process of updating my web site--hadn't touched it in four years! http://www.people.cornell.edu/pages/ar18/Amy_Ross.html
Dally - 07 Jul 2004 21:20 GMT >>A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound >>range is my guess. [quoted text clipped - 23 lines] > > Amy Thanks, Amy, that's a particularly good piece of advice about lurking and explaining the merits of using a killfile. This group is completely different when I attempt to access it via google groups - much more wild and woolley and hard to spot good things.
Dally
JMA - 07 Jul 2004 21:23 GMT > >>A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound > >>range is my guess. [quoted text clipped - 30 lines] > > Dally But there are some definite advantages to using google, especially at first. She can go in and search topics of interest, etc.
Jenn that would be the second advantage
SnugBear - 08 Jul 2004 02:40 GMT Amy wrote:
> I'm in the process of updating my web site--hadn't > touched it in four years! > http://www.people.cornell.edu/pages/ar18/Amy_Ross.html Great pic of your dad, Amy. And Meg looks just like you!
 Signature Walking on . . . Laurie in Maine 207/110 60 inches of attitude! Start: 2/02 Maintained since 2/03
A Ross - 08 Jul 2004 13:41 GMT In article <Xns951FDC8516430snugbearmidmainecom@130.133.1.4>,
> Amy wrote: > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > Great pic of your dad, Amy. And Meg looks just like you! Thanks! My sister sent some pics she took over the weekend, so I decided to fool around in Dreamweaver a bit--haven't used it much since I first got it a couple of years ago, but it's pretty intuitive.
Amy
janice - 08 Jul 2004 07:05 GMT >I know I lurked for a good long time before I ever made >my first post here, so I was pretty familiar with [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > >Amy That's a good point Amy - to lurk first. And I think if Dally does tell her friend about the group it's reasonable to expect that she'll have a read even if she doesn't contribute. If so that's fine, she can still learn something.
I remember when I first came here, several years ago, I lurked for several months and by the time I joined in already felt I "knew" the regulars. I found I was expecting them to greet me as if I was an old friend. I had to remind myself that no one here knew who I was and it was a weird feeling.
janice
Cynthia Perry - 08 Jul 2004 17:03 GMT >> A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound >> range is my guess. [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] >that will put the ball in her court, and you won't >sound preachy. Hmmm... although I just posted thinking it was a bad idea to bring up the subject... the above is perhaps a good way to get into it without pushing it on her. Then she can ask if she's interested and change the subject if she's not.
Good thinking Amy!
>I know I lurked for a good long time before I ever made >my first post here, so I was pretty familiar with [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] >Anyway, go ahead and invite her in! There's a lot of WW >and exWW WOEs here, maybe we can help her with points! True.
Cynthia
Patricia Heil - 07 Jul 2004 21:18 GMT > A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > > Dally My opinion is that IF she is into the Internet then you should let her know the group exists. Stop there. From what you say I would think she is in denial that her weight is a danger to her life. Yes, one would think that the surgery incident would be a clue but people who are addicted to one thing or another support that addiction partly by their colossal ability to ignore uncomfortable facts. My dad was an alcoholic and he and my mom were addicted to cigarettes and that's how I know. Addicts are very good at fending off advice; they get hostile.
Unless you and her family are ready and able to stage a full scale intervention, stop at telling her the group exists.
jayjay - 07 Jul 2004 21:25 GMT >A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > >Dally The only thing I can say that would be negative about this group is our lack of tolerance for idiots who refuse to accept that their eating habits are what causes them to get fat.
If this woman comes in and has this attitude that she's going to stuff cookies down her throat today because she can.. then she's going to be greated with a cold kick up the a.s with some harsh reality and she may not like the attitude she receives from some of the more outspoken members of the group. (that which you and I both fall into. :)
It may cause some upset feelings in the friendship between you two, as well as that your husbands share. So it would be something that might deture you from the invite
Jarkat2002 - 07 Jul 2004 21:50 GMT >A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. IMO she needs psychological help, not a usenet NG. People don't get to be 500 pounds without serious psychological problems. She doesn't need 'support' she needs professional help. Sending her here may very well send her over the edge w/ the way that some ppl choose to be abusive. And picking on a fat chick considering (or who has considered) weight loss surgery would just make their day.
~Kat
"The early bird gets the worm, the second mouse gets the cheese."
byakee - 07 Jul 2004 23:14 GMT One dark day on Usenet, jarkat2002@aol.comyowza (Jarkat2002) said:
> >A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > > IMO she needs psychological help, not a usenet NG. People don't get to be 500 > pounds without serious psychological problems. She doesn't need 'support' she > needs professional help. Hmm, that's a good point. My answer to Dally reflected my dealings with my own situation, but there's a big difference between 275 and 500, beyond actual numbers.
> Sending her here may very well send her over the edge > w/ the way that some ppl choose to be abusive. And picking on a fat chick > considering (or who has considered) weight loss surgery would just make their > day. I'm not sure I agree with this -- maybe I'm just missing something, but I've found just about everyone to be supportive, once one accepts that they have a weight issue and need to do something about it...
 Signature J.J. in WA * 275/230/225 (mini) (COLD to HOT for e-mail)
Dally - 08 Jul 2004 01:00 GMT > One dark day on Usenet, jarkat2002@aol.comyowza (Jarkat2002) said: > [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > with my own situation, but there's a big difference between 275 and > 500, beyond actual numbers. When I guessed 500 I was reflecting that she was in the area involving disability from the obesity. I really have no idea what the actual number is. I honestly don't care, either, but I'm cringing with horror that she's likely to see this and be upset if she only weighs 350 or something.
>>Sending her here may very well send her over the edge >>w/ the way that some ppl choose to be abusive. And picking on a fat chick >>considering (or who has considered) weight loss surgery would just make their >>day. My guess is that she's been picked on for being fat before. It's not like she hasn't noticed and she's thick-skinned enough to deal with it.
> I'm not sure I agree with this -- maybe I'm just missing something, > but I've found just about everyone to be supportive, once one accepts > that they have a weight issue and need to do something about it... I called her tonight and gave a thumbnail description of usenet - needing flame-retardent underwear, newbie mistakes, spam and trolls... she had a positive experience with another group once (sounded like a yahoo group) and that should serve as an introduction in any case.
Dally
Ignoramus14410 - 08 Jul 2004 01:18 GMT > I called her tonight and gave a thumbnail description of usenet - > needing flame-retardent underwear, newbie mistakes, spam and trolls... > she had a positive experience with another group once (sounded like a > yahoo group) and that should serve as an introduction in any case. tell her to lurk for one month...
i
SnugBear - 08 Jul 2004 02:47 GMT Ignoramus wrote:
> tell her to lurk for one month... I agree with Igor. If she's still interested after that long, it'll probably be ok. Otherwise she can just slink off and nobody will know.
I think I lurked for at least 2 or 3 months - and I was already on maintenance!
 Signature Walking on . . . Laurie in Maine 207/110 60 inches of attitude! Start: 2/02 Maintained since 2/03
byakee - 08 Jul 2004 19:58 GMT One dark day on Usenet, Ignoramus14410 <ignoramus14410@NOSPAM.14410.invalid> said:
> > I called her tonight and gave a thumbnail description of usenet - > > needing flame-retardent underwear, newbie mistakes, spam and trolls... > > she had a positive experience with another group once (sounded like a > > yahoo group) and that should serve as an introduction in any case. > > tell her to lurk for one month... I usually lurk for a week or so, depending on the group; but time limits aside, lurking is definitely the best start...
 Signature J.J. in WA * 275/230/225 (mini) (COLD to HOT for e-mail)
janice - 08 Jul 2004 06:59 GMT >A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > >Dally I would recommend anyone to come here. Even if they don't seem to be receptive to changing their ways now, they are more than likely to learn quite a lot - I know I certainly have.
Personally, I wouldn't tell anyone I know IRL about asd as I want to preserve my anonymity. Things I post here are not things I talk about to anyone outside,, even (or perhaps especially) those close to me and I would feel inhibited by having someone here who knew me.
janice
jmk - 08 Jul 2004 13:21 GMT Dally
Would it drive you nuts if she were on the list? If not, I'd go ahead and ask her. As you know, if she isn't really ready then she isn't really ready and it won't make a difference but 65 pounds lost sounds like a good step in the right direction -- that's what, about 2 pounds a month?
> A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > > Dally
 Signature jmk in NC
Cynthia Perry - 08 Jul 2004 16:59 GMT >A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > >Dally I'd say no... unless she brings up the subject. At that point, you could mention that in addition to Weight Watchers... there are Usenet newsgroups for support. (In fact, I think there is one for WW.)
Generally though, someone who is ready to help themselves will go and LOOK for that help. It sounds as though she may be there, but also may not. Just because she's joined WW right now does not mean she is totally ready to DO IT.
Cynthia
Mary M - Ohio - 09 Jul 2004 18:13 GMT Dally, I found this thread really thought-provoking, though I can't seem to generate any coherent response myself. What it brought back was being around 280+ lbs (I really don't know the exact weight but it was below my highest) -- and this really really drunk old over-made-up woman was trying to pull her car out of a university parking lot. I was walking behind her car when she started it, and when she put it in reverse, I was already past the point of danger but she was so smashed she didn't have any spatial coordination (or whatever you call it) and she slammed on the brakes and screamed, "Get out of the way, you 500-pound pig!"
Of course there were young college boys nearby (always *the* most overly cruel people to me, no matter what my age) and I yelled, "Have another drink, lady!" The boys were laughing and I just wanted to disappear.
That said, I agree with others not to beat yourself up over anything you said in the thread -- I don't know how your friend would react -- but I also agree that if she does come here it might be best to tell her what you said beforehand. Then again, I also liked the idea to wait a few months to invite her! Avoidance is always tempting. :-) Like I'm avoiding working right now (at home) -- so I'd better get back on the stick.
Mary
> A friend is morbidly obese. Super obese. 500 pound range is my guess. > She had been planning on having bariatric surgery last month but was [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] > > Dally Dally - 13 Jul 2004 04:39 GMT > Dally, I found this thread really thought-provoking, though I can't seem to > generate any coherent response myself. What it brought back was being around [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > cruel people to me, no matter what my age) and I yelled, "Have another > drink, lady!" The boys were laughing and I just wanted to disappear. Thank you for sharing that. Not that it made me feel any better about my off-handed cruelty! It's interesting how the term 500 pounds came up - neither the drunk driver nor the casual slanderer (that would be me) stopped to evaluate a reasonable estimate, now did we?
> That said, I agree with others not to beat yourself up over anything you > said in the thread -- I don't know how your friend would react -- but I also > agree that if she does come here it might be best to tell her what you said > beforehand. Then again, I also liked the idea to wait a few months to invite > her! Avoidance is always tempting. :-) Like I'm avoiding working right now > (at home) -- so I'd better get back on the stick. I didn't work up the guts to say, 'by the way, I said cruel things about you before you arrived'. In fact, it was WHILE talking to her, telling her the address, that I realized with horror that she would SEE MY POST. (Duh, like I hadn't thought of this before. So now I'm mean AND stupid. How charming.) I went to google and removed my post, but, well, you had all full-text quoted me. Sigh. Google claims another loudmouth victim.
I distinctly recall the day I realized that my 10,000 posts since 1994 were all available to be read by any of my children when they grew up. It was a bad day.
Dally
|
|
|