Weight Loss Forum / General Topics / July 2004
How Olympic gymnasts eat: you may be surprised
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Ignoramus1802 - 09 Jul 2004 18:17 GMT http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=541&u=/ap/20040628/ap_on_he_me/fit_gym nastics_diets_1&printer=1
What Do the Olympic Gymnasts Eat?
Mon Jun 28,12:27 PM ET Add Health - AP to My Yahoo!
By EDDIE PELLS, AP Sports Writer
ANAHEIM, Calif. - With rock-hard biceps and abs that would make a bodybuilder jealous, Stephen McCain (news - web sites) doesn't need to lose weight. Yet count him as a devotee of the increasingly popular low-carbohydrate diet.
Yahoo! Health Have questions about your health? Find answers here.
A 2000 U.S. Olympian trying to make it back to the Games this year, McCain started doing the high-protein, low-carb thing well before it became the biggest diet fad in the country.
"I used to think it was all about carbs, carbs, carbs to get the energy," he said. "But over time, I realized I performed better when I kept that stuff in check."
That's because gymnastics, unlike swimming or long-distance running, is considered an "anaerobic" sport, one in which short, intense bursts of power are much more important than endurance.
"Over the span of a three-hour workout, we're probably only up on the equipment for 15 minutes," McCain said. The longest routine for a man or woman is the floor exercise, which lasts between 60 and 90 seconds.
Thus, having lots of complex sugars stored up ? the kind produced by carbohydrates ? does not help a gymnast that much. Those energy spurts are best provided by a diet high in protein. Most gymnasts try to get between 60 percent and 70 percent of their calories from proteins (like meats and cheeses), the rest from carbs (like whole-grain pasta, fruits, vegetables) and fats (like oils from peanuts). And, as has been proven by all the Atkins, South Beach and Zone diets so popular these days, high-protein regimens help gymnasts keep their weight down.
The weight issue can be a touchy subject in gymnastics, especially on the women's side. Eating disorders have long been common in a sport in which young girls are urged to stay lean, yet keep the muscle that allows them to explode and do such amazing tricks on the floor, uneven bars and beam.
But done correctly, diets can produce gymnasts like Courtney McCool, Tabitha Yim or national co-champion Courtney Kupets (news - web sites), all fit, trim young women who hardly seem to fit some of the worst stereotypes of the sport.
They eat several times a day, all in small quantities: egg whites for breakfast, a small piece of chicken for lunch, small snacks of cheese and vegetables in between meals and maybe some fish and fruit for dinner.
Is it what most 16-year-old girls would be eating? Probably not, but these young women are in fabulous shape. And with the desire to be a world-class gymnast come sacrifices, the likes of which all these athletes know they must make when they get into the sport.
"It's just something you have to deal with," McCool said. "You have to be not just physically tough, but mentally tough."
No sport has been watched more closely ? or criticized ? for its weight issues than gymnastics. Christy Henrich, a member of the 1989 U.S. world championship team, died at age 22 in 1994 after long battles with anorexia nervosa and bulimia. Stories abound of former American team coordinator Bela Karolyi hectoring his young gymnasts for being out of shape and fat.
Just as revealing are myriad pictures of 14-year-old girls who look no older than 8 or 9.
"You see things that are inappropriate that shouldn't be done," longtime gymnastics coach Steve Rybacki said. "The key is finding the right balance."
Steve, who coaches alongside his wife, Beth, a former gymnast herself, said he has learned over the years that weight issues with female gymnasts are best discussed woman-to-woman.
"Getting that kind of feedback from a guy can be a real negative thing," Rybacki said.
On the women's side of the sport, diets can be more easily monitored simply because female gymnasts at the Olympic level are usually between ages 15 and 19 ? in other words, they still live at home.
Once a month, they go to training camps held at a Texas ranch owned by Karolyi and his wife, Martha, who is the current national team coordinator. Their daughter, Andrea, is a certified nutritionist who does the food service at the camps.
The menu for lunch at one recent training camp was a salad bar, pork loin, vegetables, potatoes and fruit.
"My mom and I work on the menus," Andrea Karolyi said. "She's very involved in the nutrition. She wants to make sure everything is well-balanced."
The biggest problem, Rybacki said, is finding enough kinds of food to keep teenage girls ? in large part, a notoriously picky bunch of eaters anyway ? happy.
"You're taking a menu that's already limited because there aren't a lot of foods they like," Rybacki said, "and then you're cutting it down even further. That's the challenge."
Most of the men, meanwhile, are in their 20s, and don't get as much help.
"I'm 30 years old, so I'm going to do what I'm going to do," McCain said. "But I think I've finally got a real good grip on what's right."
Many see irony in the fact that one of America's best female gymnasts, Carly Patterson (news - web sites), is being featured on the side of McDonald's bags this summer as part of the fast-food chain's Olympics promotions.
Rybacki said, however, that a little bit of off-the-diet eating is allowed, "as long as it's looked at as a reward, something special, and not part of the regular routine."
McCool certainly knows.
"I don't like hamburgers," she said. "I eat a lot of chicken. Some steak. Mostly just chicken ... or Taco Bell."
Chris Braun - 09 Jul 2004 22:29 GMT An interesting article. But the lead-in text saying "count him as a devotee of the increasingly popular low-carbohydrate diet" is perhaps a little misleading. Reading the article makes it clear that these athletes are not eating the typical high-fat Atkins style of diet, but are in fact focusing on lots of lean protein with very moderate healthy carbs and good fats.
By the way, Olympic weightlifting is also an anaerobic sport, and the top athletes I've known follow a very similar diet.
Chris 262/144/ (145-150)
Dally - 10 Jul 2004 03:51 GMT > An interesting article. But the lead-in text saying "count him as a > devotee of the increasingly popular low-carbohydrate diet" is perhaps [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > By the way, Olympic weightlifting is also an anaerobic sport, and the > top athletes I've known follow a very similar diet. It's also the high glycemic index diet, the diabetic exchange diet, the Zone diet and the South Beach Diet. Bill Phillips, author of "Body for Life" calls it "eating clean".
Dally, who had pork loin on a salad for lunch today
Ignoramus1802 - 10 Jul 2004 04:26 GMT >> An interesting article. But the lead-in text saying "count him as a >> devotee of the increasingly popular low-carbohydrate diet" is perhaps [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] > > It's also the high glycemic index diet, the diabetic exchange diet, the low glycemic index?
i
> Zone diet and the South Beach Diet. Bill Phillips, author of "Body for > Life" calls it "eating clean". > > Dally, who had pork loin on a salad for lunch today Ignoramus1802 - 10 Jul 2004 04:21 GMT > An interesting article. But the lead-in text saying "count him as a > devotee of the increasingly popular low-carbohydrate diet" is perhaps > a little misleading. Reading the article makes it clear that these > athletes are not eating the typical high-fat Atkins style of diet, but > are in fact focusing on lots of lean protein with very moderate > healthy carbs and good fats. Well, Atkins is officially low carb, you can make it high fat (like most people do), or high protein. Both would be possible on Atkins.
> By the way, Olympic weightlifting is also an anaerobic sport, and the > top athletes I've known follow a very similar diet. Never knew that. Thanks.
i
MH - 10 Jul 2004 06:15 GMT http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=541&u=/ap/20040628/ap_on_he_me/fit _gymnastics_diets_1&printer=1
> What Do the Olympic Gymnasts Eat? What a fluff, useless article that was!
In the real world of gymnastics, according to Cathy Rigby and other retired gymnasts, it's a world of anorexia and health problems.
You do realize that many ex female gymnasts of that high skill level cannot have children, right? And, because of their anorexia, their bones are so shallow and destroyed that they will have health problems forever. I should say it's probably the same with the men.
Look into the reality of it all, not the PR crap.
MH - 10 Jul 2004 06:17 GMT http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=541&u=/ap/20040628/ap_on_he_me/fit
> _gymnastics_diets_1&printer=1 > > [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > > Look into the reality of it all, not the PR crap. Sorry for continuing the cross post. Cross posting sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Roger Zoul - 10 Jul 2004 13:45 GMT http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=541&u=/ap/20040628/ap_on_he_me/fit
|| _gymnastics_diets_1&printer=1 ||| [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] || || Look into the reality of it all, not the PR crap. perhaps that was all before LC came back! the more modern gymnasts could maintain weight without purging and straving...eating LC and doing all of that exercise.
Ignoramus9040 - 10 Jul 2004 14:26 GMT > http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=541&u=/ap/20040628/ap_on_he_me/fit >|| _gymnastics_diets_1&printer=1 [quoted text clipped - 16 lines] > maintain weight without purging and straving...eating LC and doing all of > that exercise. Roger, the original article was very clear on realities of gymnastics, as follows:
``The weight issue can be a touchy subject in gymnastics, especially on the women's side. Eating disorders have long been common in a sport in which young girls are urged to stay lean, yet keep the muscle that allows them to explode and do such amazing tricks on the floor, uneven bars and beam.''
So, Martha is wrong, when she implies that the article was useless because it did not mention EDs among gymnasts. It did mention EDs and gave them fair consideration.
i
Roger Zoul - 10 Jul 2004 15:56 GMT :: In article <10evp4aqh6ukuac@corp.supernews.com>, Roger Zoul wrote: ::: MH wrote: ::::: "Ignoramus1802" <ignoramus1802@NOSPAM.1802.invalid> wrote in ::::: message news:ccmjuk$iv0$0@pita.alt.net... http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=541&u=/ap/20040628/ap_on_he_me/fit
::::: _gymnastics_diets_1&printer=1 :::::: [quoted text clipped - 30 lines] :: because it did not mention EDs among gymnasts. It did mention EDs and :: gave them fair consideration. That is what I was trying point out to MH -- perhaps some updating is in order. Talking about Cathy Rigby -- hasn't she been out of competing for many, many moons now? Using anything she said as a basis for comment might end up being quite dated.
I think the article makes a lot of good sense, personally, even though I thought some of the comments might have been inaccurate.
Ignoramus9040 - 10 Jul 2004 19:38 GMT >:: In article <10evp4aqh6ukuac@corp.supernews.com>, Roger Zoul wrote: >::: MH wrote: [quoted text clipped - 41 lines] > many, many moons now? Using anything she said as a basis for comment might > end up being quite dated. I doubt that she even read the article.
> I think the article makes a lot of good sense, personally, even though I > thought some of the comments might have been inaccurate. It only makes sense that to be so light and strong as to win olympic competition (to be the best in the world, in a sense), many athletes would resort to extreme dietary measures. Hard to expect it to be otherwise.
i
Tony Lew - 10 Jul 2004 16:40 GMT > http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=541&u=/ap/20040628/ap_on_he_me/fit > _gymnastics_diets_1&printer=1 [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > shallow and destroyed that they will have health problems forever. I should > say it's probably the same with the men. Probably not. Men's gymnastics consists of different events where strength seems important, not slenderness. The male gymnasts I've seen in the Olympics are short but look very muscular and well nourished. They look like "vertically challenged" body builders, not anorexics.
> Look into the reality of it all, not the PR crap.
|
|
|